Explain one criticism of both mill and kant

Reference no: EM133595242

Question: This assignment presents another "What would you do?" scenario that necessitates ethical reasoning. Though it might seem a bit far-fetched, we often encounter similar situations. This assignment clarifies the importance of one's ethical frameworks and demonstrates how different might be our decisions when operating under different ethical frameworks.

This assignment supports the following unit objectives:

Explain the main features of the ethical theories of Ruth Benedict and James Rachels, Plato, Aristotle, Kant, and Mill.
Analyze the strengths and weaknesses of ethical relativism, ethical egoism, virtue ethics, deontological ethics, utilitarianism, and other major ethical theories discussed.
Tasks

Read the following thought experiment from Philippa Foot and then make an essay that answers the questions that follow:

"Let us consider [...] a pair of cases which I shall call Rescue I and Rescue II. In the first Rescue story we are hurrying in our jeep to save some people - let there be five of them - who are imminently threatened by the ocean tide. We have not a moment to spare, so when we hear of a single person who also needs rescuing from some other disaster we say regretfully that we cannot rescue him, but must leave him to die. To most of us this seems clear [...]. This is Rescue I and with it I contrast Rescue II. In this second story we are again hurrying to the place where the tide is coming in in order to rescue the party of people, but this time it is relevant that the road is narrow and rocky. In this version the lone individual is trapped (do not ask me how) on the path. If we are to rescue the five we would have to drive over him. But can we do so? If we stop he will be all right eventually: he is in no danger unless from us. But of course all five of the others will be drowned. As in the first story our choice is between a course of action which will leave one man dead and five alive at the end of the day and a course of action which will have the opposite result. (Philippa Foot, "Killing and Letting Die," from Abortion and Legal Perspectives, eds. Garfield and Hennessey, 2004, University of Massachusetts Press)

What would Mill tell the rescuer to do, in Rescue I and Rescue II, according to his theory of utilitarianism? Be clear in explaining Mill's recommendation, and how he would justify it. In doing so, you must include a discussion of the following:

The Principle of Utility and how it would specifically apply in this situation-who gets "counted" and how?
What would Kant tell the rescuer to do, in Rescue I and Rescue II, according to his deontological theory? Be clear in explaining Kant's recommendation and how he would justify it. In doing so, you must include a discussion of the following:
The first version of the Categorical Imperative and how it would specifically apply in these two situations (hint, you have to say what the maxim would be and what duty would be generated according to it).

The second version of the Categorical Imperative and how it would specifically apply in this situation.

Explain one criticism of both Mill and Kant. Afterward, argue for which ethical approach, on your view is superior. Be specific and provide reasons for your claim.

Reference no: EM133595242

Questions Cloud

Develop and display a control chart for the process : Calculate and define process metics including variations and process capability. Develop and display a control chart for the process.

What are some examples of the four principle of ethics : What are the four principles of ethics of ASHA and What are some examples of the four principle of ethics of ASHA

Should we expect oculus to have entry timing advantages : Which of these two patents do you think gives Oculus a stronger protection and why? Based on the reading for this week, should we expect Oculus to have entry

List opportunities for innovation and commercialization : List out 25 opportunities for Innovation and Commercialization. Use a criteria matrix to rate them. Select one, map its development historically to future goal.

Explain one criticism of both mill and kant : Explain one criticism of both Mill and Kant. Afterward, argue for which ethical approach, on your view is superior. Be specific and provide reasons for your

How often will the team meet and for how long : Do not talk about what may already be in place, but what you believe would be the most effective. How often will this team meet and for how long?

Article-temporary employment agency workers in montreal : Familiar with the article: "Temporary Employment Agency Workers in Montreal: Immigrant and Migrant Workers' Struggles in Canada? by Aziz & Henaway.

Can you name at least eight of them : Can you name at least eight of them? Tourists will have diverse expectations and needs. Name at least six of them. Further cultural differences may arise from

Discuss quality robust products and taguchi concepts : Discuss quality robust products and Taguchi concepts. Should every organization use the Taguchi concepts? Why or why not?

User Account

All Pages