Explain main issue or problem under critical consideration

Assignment Help English
Reference no: EM131215499

Critical Thinking in Action

Background

What is Critical Thinking?

The head of your organization pulled you aside and asked you to review a workplace dispute. She said, "Apply your best critical thinking to figure out what happened and what decision can best remedy this situation." She wants your analysis in two weeks.

To begin, let's consider what it means to engage in critical thinking. While the application of critical thinking may vary across disciplines, the steps are universal. Adapted from the writings of Bassham, Irwin, Nardone, and Wallace (2011); Lau (2011); and Lau and Chan (2015), critical thinking involves thinking clearly and systematically, and encompasses

• Formulating ideas succinctly and precisely
• Identifying the relevance and importance of ideas
• Understanding the logical connections between ideas
• Identifying, constructing and evaluating arguments, claims, and evidence
• Recognizing explicit and implicit assumptions, arguments, and biases
• Detecting inconsistencies and common mistakes in reasoning
• Formulating clear defensible ideas and conclusions
• Evaluating the pros and cons of decisions
• Reflecting on one's own beliefs and values
• Applying ethical decision making

The steps involved in critical thinking can be employed universally, in the analysis of all thoughts and actions -whether you are analyzing documents, ideas, assertions, or the quality of decisions/solutions.

Most importantly, critical thinking is purposeful. It is not restricted solely to information gathering, nor is it about being "negative and fault-finding" (Bassham et. al., 2011 p. 1). As Lau and Chan write, "A critical thinker is able to deduce consequences from what he knows, and he knows how to make use of information to solve problems, and to seek relevant sources of information to inform himself" (2015, para 1). While the process of critical thinking may involve exposing untruths and poor reasoning, it also involves engaging in cooperative reasoning for the purposes of shared goals and decision making. We engage in the steps of critical thinking to learn deeply, to improve our ideas, to strengthen arguments and to "enhance work processes and improve social institutions" (Lau and Chan, 2015 para 2).

Critical thinking aligns with and informs ethical reasoning and decision-making. Internet marketing expert Nick Melillo (2010) writes.

Critical thinking plays a large role in ethics because it is the process by which we determine for ourselves whether or not something is right or wrong. In a sense, critical thinking is a form of analysis and determination of fact vs. fiction, identifying the unknown, coming to an understanding, etc... By taking the path of a critical thinker, a person develops a mental process of evaluation which helps to determine their ethical standards. (p. 1)

The process of critical thinking helps us weigh and verify information, assess intent, and consider consequences, thereby enabling more effective ethical decision-making.

Hereford (2015) suggests critical thinking requires a particular mindset that includes being able to

• Rely on reason instead of emotions
• Assess a broad range of perspectives and viewpoints
• Consider new evidence, explanations, findings, and alternative interpretations
• Reassess information
• Suspend personal prejudices and biases
• Contemplate all reasonable possibilities
• Avoid quick judgments

In this assignment, you'll take some time to adopt a framework for critical thinking. Then you'll put the steps of critical thinking into practice by responding to the company-head's request for a critical analysis of the ongoing dispute.

The Assignment

Step 1: Review the Critical Thinking to serve as a framework for critical thinking. Use it to structure your thinking for this assignment and for others in your studies at UMUC.

The framework is based on FOUR key steps, each of which has several sub-steps.

1. Identify and clearly explain the main issue or problem under critical consideration.
2. Gather and analyze information to explore/investigate the issue or problem.
3. Consider and analyze other possible viewpoints, conclusions or decision/solutions to the issue or problem
4. Develop well-reasoned ideas, conclusions and/or decisions/solutions, checking them against relevant criteria and benchmarks

Step 2: Read the Case Study- Accident on the Job, and analyze it using the framework provided by the TGS Critical Thinking Rubric. Use the rubric's four key steps as the format framework of a short position paper (details in the "Deliverables" section below). Employ the sub-steps within each of the four key steps to further direct your analysis.

Assignment Deliverables

Write a short paper (1,000-1,200 words, double spaced, plus a cover page and references) that critically analyses the ideas or position presented in the case reading. The major sections of your paper should include the following:

1. Introduction
2. Explanation of the Issue or Problem
3. Analysis of the Information
4. Analysis of Alternative Viewpoints, Conclusions or Solutions
5. Personal or Summarized Conclusions and Proposed Decisions
6. Conclusion

Follow these guidelines:

• Use the TGS Critical Thinking Rubric to guide your analysis: Critical Thinking Rubric, expanded.
• Use the TGS Written Communications Rubric to guide your writing: Comm Rubric Expanded Rev 032416.pdf.
• Draw in references from at least one reputable outside resource related to the topic to support your conclusions or proposed decisions.
• Employ APA Style 6ed for format and citation guidance: APA Citation Examples (UMUC Library); Sample Paper to Show Appropriate APA Style.
• Include an APA title page and Reference page.

Remember: Even though I have suggested the major sections for your short paper, you should still follow best practices for structuring the paper.

• An effective introduction grabs the reader's attention and sets the tone and direction for the rest of the paper. In reading an introduction, the reader should have a clear idea of what will follow. Supporting paragraphs move the reader from the general introduction to the more specific aspects of your analysis in the paper.

• The body paragraphs show how the information you are providing supports and relates to your thesis. Paragraphs across and within sections need to effectively transition from one to the next.

• Each paragraph should include a topic sentence, which contains the main point of the paragraph.

• The Conclusion (#6) brings to a close what you have presented in your paper.

References

Bassham, G., Irwin, W., Nardone, H., & Wallace, J. (2011). Critical thinking: A student's introduction (4th ed). New York, NY: The McGraw Hill Companies.

Fisher, A. (2011). Critical thinking: An introduction. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

Hereford, Z. (2015). How to think critically and problem solve. Retrieved from https://www.essentiallifeskills.net/thinkcritically.html

Lau, J. (2011). An introduction to critical thinking and creativity: Think more, think better. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Lau, J., & Chan, J. (2015). What is critical thinking? Retrieved from https://philosophy.hku.hk/think/critical/ct.php

Melillo, N. (2010). What is the relationship between critical thinking and ethics? Retrieved from https://www.triadsearchmarketing.com/

Reference no: EM131215499

Questions Cloud

Creative brief for communicating the product : A creative brief for communicating the product to its target audiences (needed to include objective for the ad campaign/ad, the target audience, the message theme, support facts for the theme, plus URL to use & any disclaimer or constraints).
Recent conflict rationalization purchase by a group member : Briefly discuss a recent conflict rationalization purchase by a group member, relative, or friend. Clearly delineate the emotional motives, pragmatic considerations, and rationalization of the conflict.
Explain the company global strategy : In this assignment, you will analyze the balance of local standardized products globally. In your essay, include the following: Explain the company's global strategy. Discuss how cultural differences are considered and managed.
Create a new and successful marketing campaign : The venture was not a success. While it enjoyed economies of scale, the marketing campaign did not engage new customers. Which information is essential to create a new and successful marketing campaign?
Explain main issue or problem under critical consideration : Identify and clearly explain the main issue or problem under critical consideration. Gather and analyze information to explore/investigate the issue or problem.
Identification of professional accounting issue in workplace : How do you applied knowledge from this degree study in solving your workplace problems, including appropriate analysis and justification
Provide an example of how to use the formula : What explanation would you give so that your staff understands that formula? Provide an example of how to use the formula. Develop a matrix using the formula as part of your example.
What is the equilibrium price quantity and profit for firm : Chuckie B Corp. is considering implementing a proprietary technology with a one-time sunk cost of $200. Once this investment is made, marginal cost will be reduced to $40. Gene Gene has no access to this or any other cost saving technology, and it..
Areas of the united states economy : From the scenario, discuss two (2) areas of the United States economy that Ronald Reagan deregulated in the eighties. Explain at least two (2) methods the Reagan Administration used to deregulate these particular agencies or programs.

Reviews

Write a Review

English Questions & Answers

  Write essay about the monkey king ?a superhero tale of china

Write an essay about The Monkey King: ?A Superhero Tale of China.

  What senses amy tan uses to enhance her descriptions

write your first draft, and then write your revised draft. Make sure you demonstrate the elements of a good description and use sensory details (touch, smell, taste, sound, and sight).

  The fin-de-siegravecle was both the culmination of a

the fin-de-siegravecle was both the culmination of a century of industrial progress and imperial expansion and a period

  Spectrum of national perspectives

A major shift in American literature after World War II was the inclusion of new voices in the spectrum of national perspectives. Examples of works that maintain ties to a previous culture while establishing links to America include Sandra Cisnero..

  How did the national view of the chicago police department

How did the new community policing strategy fit with the need to increase the accountability of police officers and the decentralization of responsibility?

  How do imperialism continue to influence the way asian women

According to Sunny Woan, how do Imperialism, Orientalism, and Sexism continue to influence the way Asian women are treated in the law and in society?

  Sharp break from the immediate neo-classical past

Scholars say that movements in culture often come as reactions to previous movements. Show how Romanticism reflects a sharp break from the immediate Neo-Classical past.

  Discuss nature as a source of instruction and delight

Discuss nature as a source of instruction, delight, and nourishment for the soul; return to nature as a source of inspiration and wisdom; life in nature often contrasted with the unnatural constraints of society.

  Case study on the character of holden caulfield

Do a case study on the character of Holden Caulfield. Explain what you believe he is going through or may suffer from by using psychological outside sources.

  Poem presentation-after great pain, a formal feeling comes

need the Theme, Point of view,Plot, Character, and a summary of the poem for a presentation-After great pain, a formal feeling comes

  Literature review for the given topic -turnover solutions

Need a literature review for the topic (Turnover solutions). In my research I want to cover the following (one paragraph for each): Work compensation + study reference, Work satisfaction + study reference and Time work flexibility + study reference

  How could you combine the following two sentences into a

1. which of the following is a fragment?a. the dancer floated across the stage.b. the canoe with the blue stripes.c.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd