Examine a specific entry from wikipedia

Assignment Help History
Reference no: EM131547798

Many students assume that the online, free encyclopedia, Wikipedia is a valid, authoritative and useful reference source for their scholarly work as a student at NVCC. Many teachers say that Wikipedia is garbage and should never be used. Which is it?

In this assignment, we will be examining just how authoritative (and stable) Wikipedia (aka wiki) is. First, you will examine a specific entry from Wikipedia and check for changes that have occurred over a period of six months, and then you will compare the information from the Wikipedia entry with the information from an established reference source such as the Encyclopedia Britannica (EB).

Since you may have never really looked carefully at a Wikipedia entry, I want you first to look at my Explanation of Using Wikipediabefore you start this paper assignment.

For your comparison of a Wikipedia entry with the same entry in EB, you should choose a research term that is in some way relevant to the material that you have covered in your course, and that term must be clear, focused and doable.

For example, "World War II" or "The Roman Empire" or "communism" are historical terms that are too large to analyze in this assignment. You simply are not going to be able to expertly compare 12 pages of material on, for example, World War I, with the twelve pages of material in EB. It is often easiest to pick an individual.

Your Wikipedia entry must be approved by your professor. We do not accept terms that are primarily U.S. history. nor do we accept any World War II terms, national socialism related entries, or Hitler, Stalin or Napoleon. Your professor has final say on whether an entry is appropriate.

You have a textbook with hundreds of pages of history that you should use to help you decide on a term--check the book's index. Be sure that your Wikipedia term also appears in Encyclopedia Britannica. (See How to Access Encyclopaedia Britannica Online.) If you are unable to access Britannica, please let me know, and I will suggest an alternative reference source. If you are not a registered NVCC student, you may have trouble accessing Encyclopedia Britannica, please contact your instructor (and don't wait until the night before the assignment is due).

You must email your research choice to your instructor for approval at least two days before the assignment is due.
With the permission of your instructor, instead of using EB, you may compare your entry with the equivalent Wikipedia entry in a foreign language, for example, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beslan_school_hostage_crisis and ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/????????????????_???_?_???????.

Your analysis paper should be no more than two pages. double-spaced, one-inch margins, font size 10 or 12. Your paper should assess the overall stability and authoritative nature of the Wikipedia entry for your research term. Consider such questions:

How much has your selected Wikipedia entry changed (or not changed) over a period of at least six months?

Do we have any idea of the credentials of the people who created the Wikipedia information, or who made the changes?

Were any changes the result of sound, scholarly research?

Why did the entry change?

How does the Wikipedia information compare with the information in EB? This is the most important part of your analysis, and you should provide a specific explanation about the Wikipedia entry's information in comparison to the information in EB.

Wikipedia: good or bad? That is partly what you are answering in this assignment, but I would also like to point out that a "Wikipedia" article can often be an excellent starting point (not the end point) for research on a topic or a quick source of general information. For example, I often check Wikipedia if I am looking for the birth or death dates of a historical figure.

I would also point out that a Wikipedia entry is especially valuable when it includes footnotes, citations of sources and suggested sources for further information (often in the form of external links).

Finally, Wikipedia can be extremely useful on topics of relatively newer historical events. For example, in my HIS 242 (History of Russia II) course, I ask that students check the entry for the Beslan School Hostage crisis. This is an exceptional article--although its quality varies a bit from month to month.

Reference no: EM131547798

Questions Cloud

Write a paragraph commenting on the life of ivan iv : Read some comments about Ivan IV by a contemporary Englishman and--in the realm of "Can you believe it?"--this account of Ivan's life.
What is the amount of the expected dividend in year five : What is the amount of the expected dividend in year 5?
What is the value of the portfolio in one year : After the payoffs have been equalized and the riskless hedged investment is created, what is the value of the portfolio in one year?
Size of the federal bureaucracy : Do you believe that the size of the federal bureaucracy has kept pace with the increasing demands on government?
Examine a specific entry from wikipedia : Examine a specific entry from Wikipedia and check for changes that have occurred over a period of six months, and then you will compare the information.
Evaluate a particular piece of legislation : Identify and evaluate a particular piece of "legislation" that should be designed & enacted. Clearly explain the issues, which warrant the new legislation
Announced that future dividends will be increasing : The company just announced that future dividends will be increasing by 2 percent annually. How much are you willing to pay for one share of this stock.
Describe emotional intelligence portrayed by leader in event : Previous to the 1990s, an individual's Intelligent Quotient (IQ) remained an unquestioned, central standard of learning. With a high IQ, it may be assumed.
Discuss drafts of your business model and strategic plan : Discuss drafts of your Business Model and Strategic Plan, Part I Individual assignment with all team members.

Reviews

Write a Review

History Questions & Answers

  Radically influenced protestantism and european society

John Calvin was a French Lawyer and Theologian who radically influenced Protestantism and European society. His philosophies include all of the following, except

  What problems did women face in industrial workplace

What additional problems and challenges did women and minorities face in the industrial workplace? Discuss the difference between vertical and horizontal integration.

  Explain the major internal conflicts roman catholic church

Explain the major internal conflicts the Roman Catholic Church experienced from the 300s to the 1500s and the major effects.

  Why could china re-create its empire

Why could China re-create its empire-just 400 years after the fall of the Han-but Rome could not? Are there similarities between the Qin-Han transition and that of the Sui-Tang

  Era of mass culture and consumption

Why is the twentieth century considered an era of mass culture and consumption?

  What motivated the leaders of anticolonial movements

One important story in twentieth-century world history was anticolonialism, as Africans and Asians challenged the dominance of the Western powers.

  Craft an essay discussing the domestic and foreign policy

craft an essay discussing the domestic and foreign policy of your selection

  How did the romans come to dominate italy

How did the Romans come to dominate Italy, and what political institutions and changes did they bring about? How did Rome expand its power beyond Italy, and what were the effects of this success?

  Hitler published mein kampf-lebensraum figure

In early 1925, Hitler published Mein Kampf. What were his ideas, what did he say should be Germany’s objectives? How does Lebensraum figure in? Why could Stalin make the claim that Soviet involvement in the European front of World War II was the deci..

  Peoples of africa and eurasia explored and settled

Explain why peoples of Africa and Eurasia explored and settled the Americas before peoples of the Americas explored and settled Africa and/or Eurasia . In your essay contrast the development of the two sets of peoples and cite major events in the pro..

  To what extent was the stability of each regime determined

To what extent was the stability of each regime determined by its ability to fulfill basic consumer demands? How did non-material factors, such as a government's foreign policy successes or failures.

  How were african-americans used in the war effort

How were African-Americans used in the war effort by both the Union and the Confederacy? What difficulties did they face in war service? The response should be 500 words.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd