Ethical dilemma directing the directors

Assignment Help Business Management
Reference no: EM131110912

ETHICAL DILEMMA Directing the Directors

One critical structural element of most corporations is the board of directors. In principle, chief executives report to the directors. In practice, however, boards do not always function as you might expect. Boards were implicated in many corporate scandals of the past decade-either because they actively condoned unethical behavior or because they turned a blind eye to it. Many also blamed lax board oversight for the financial meltdown and ensuing recession. Business media have called boards "absolutely useless" and "a sham."

One of the keys to reforming board behavior is ensuring that boards function independently of the CEO. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) have set guidelines for the independence of directors-who should not be otherwise affiliated with, employed by, or connected to the organization they direct. The more independent the structure and composition of the board, the better the corporation will be governed, and the more effective it will be.

One example of nonindependence came to light in 2010. In addition to $225,000 in cash and deferred stock he was paid to function as a member of Citibank's board, Robert Joss earned $350,000 in consulting fees for advising the bank on projects "from time to time." When asked to comment, Joss replied, "I'm comfortable that I can handle that."

Such examples seem egregious violations of independence in board structures. Yet, evidence on the link between board independence and firm performance is surprisingly weak. One recent review concluded, "There is no evidence of systematic relationships between board composition and corporate financial performance." Another structural issue is how the roles of the CEO and chairperson are filled-for instance, whether these positions are held by different people. Most argue that for the board to function independently, the roles must be separate, and Bloomberg Businessweek estimates that 37 percent of the 500 largest U.S. corporations do split them. Yet here, too, the evidence is weak: it doesn't appear that corporations with separate CEOs and chairs perform any better than those where the CEO and chairperson are one and the same.

Reference no: EM131110912

Questions Cloud

Contrast two natural disasters : Compare and contrast two natural disasters. Provide examples on how they are similar and different regarding early detection, mitigation, preparedness, response and recovery.
Write a piece of narrative writing : Write a piece of narrative writing and i would like to know some phrases to use to create suspense
Recruitment and six challenges associated with selection : Analyze six challenges (e.g., legal, ethical, moral, and operational) related to recruitment and six challenges associated with selection. Include a balance of information on both internal and external challenges, and explain how these challenges..
What do you think are the most important messages for eboni : After watching the video about Eboni, describe her response to the situation in terms of her developmental stage. How would you, as a social worker, respond?
Ethical dilemma directing the directors : One critical structural element of most corporations is the board of directors. In principle, chief executives report to the directors. In practice, however, boards do not always function as you might expect.
Relationship between independent and dependent variables : Explain how references explain the relationship between independent and dependent variables, and competing arguments
Basic functions of management : Define the contribution of employee empowerment as a catalyst for change into a global organization. Explain how you can motivate and manage change, taking into account the following concepts:
Fixed and random factors in design of experiments : Explain the differences between fixed and random factors in Design of Experiments (DoE).
What interesting or helpful about this view : Explain your answers to the "believing" questions about the three (3) premises opposing your position from the Procon.org website. Examine at least two (2) types of biases that you likely experienced as you evaluated the premises for and against ..

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Management Questions & Answers

  Materials handling-packaging field research report

You are a consultant hired by a consumer products research company to analyze the packaging of various consumer products. Your first assignment is to go into a retail store and pick three products which consumers purchase on a frequent basis.

  Organizational behavior research topic

Organizational Behavior Research Topic - What is the focus for your project, and how is it relevant to the issues studied in this course?

  How could the unethical behavior be avoided or resolved

Unethical Business Research-Find article that discusses unethical business research conduct that has resulted in individuals or firm being convicted or tried for- What unethical research behavior was involved? How could the unethical behavior be av..

  Quantitative and mixed methods approaches

Toward that end one valuable exercise involves returning to the triumvirate of quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods approaches and creating hypotheses as well as descriptive questions accordingly

  Question regarding the firm after-tax cost

A firm's after-tax cost to borrow is 7% and their shareholders require a return of 17%. They provide excerpts from their financial statements below. Calculate WACC.

  Build a motel for slumber motels corporation

Rite and Bilt Contractors Inc. agrees to build a motel for Slumber Motels Corporation. The project proceeds according to plan, however before it is done, Slumber tells Rite and Bilt to quit. Rite and Bilt may recover

  Explain hofstedes five cultural dimensions

Explain Hofstedes Five Cultural Dimensions of a specific culture - Identify at least one continuum of each dimension and describe the degree of influence that they have on cultural process.

  What are the implications of situation

Discuss case in terms of nonverbal behavior and other topics presented in this chapter. What are the implications of this situation?

  A comprehensive social security system

A comprehensive social security system

  Fannie mae - organizational culture

Prepare a paragraph or two describing for how Fannie Mae in 2004, organizational structure was very poor- hence they ran into all their problems.

  Employer to fire an employee without a good reason

Should the law allow an employer to fire an employee without a good reason? Conduct research to provide examples to support your position and use your own personal employment experiences when possible.

  What is the companys mission statement

Identify the major issues and/or opportunities that the company faces based on your analysis - Generate a hypothesis surrounding each issue and research questions to use for conducting analysis.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd