Estimate the effect of seat belt use on fatalities

Assignment Help Microeconomics
Reference no: EM131026338

1. Consider the one-variable regression model: Yi = β0 + β1Xi + ui, and suppose that it satisfies the assumption in Key Concept 4.3 (from your textbook). Suppose that Yi is measured with error, so that the data are Y^i = Yi + ωi, where ωi is the measurement error which is i.i.d. and independent of Yi and Xi. Consider the population regression Y^i = β0 + β1Xi + vi, where vi is the regression error using the mismeasured dependent variable Y˜i.

(a) Show that vi = ui + wi.

(b) Show that the regression Y˜i = β0 + β1Xi + vi satisfies the assumptions in Key Concept 4.3.

(c) Are the OLS estimators consistent? Can confidence intervals be constructed in the usual way? If so, how do they differ from those that we would obtain if we had (measurement error free) observations on Yi? Explain.

Now, assume Yi is measured without error, but Xi is measured with error. Let X˜i = Xi + ωi denote the observed regressor, where wi denotes a generic measurement error. Now, the population regression is given by Yi = β0 + β1i + vi. Note this is not the same vi as above.

(d) Express vi in terms of ui and ωi.

(e) Is there Error-In-Variables bias, if ωi is uncorrelated with Xi? If so, what is the direction of the bias? Explain. You may assume Cov(Xi, ui) = Cov(ui, ωi)= 0.

2.

Traffic crashes are the leading cause of death for Americans between the ages of 5 and 32. Through various spending policies, the federal government has encouraged states to institute mandatory seat belt laws to reduce the number of fatalities and serious injuries. In this exercise you will investigate how effective these laws are in increasing seat belt use and reducing fatalities. The data file Seatbelts contains a panel of data from 50 states plus the District of Columbia for the years 1983 through 1997.1 A detailed description is given in Seatbelts_Description.

a. Estimate the effect of seat belt use on fatalities by regressing FatalityRate on sb_useage, speed65, speed70, ba08, drinkage21, ln(income), and age. Does the estimated regression suggest that increased seat belt use reduces fatalities?

b. Do the results change when you add state fixed effects? Provide an intuitive explanation for why the results changed.

c. Do the results change when you add time fixed effects plus state fixed effects? d. Which regression specification-(a), (b), or (c)-is most reliable? Explain why.

e. Using the results in (c), discuss the size of the coefficient on sb_useage. Is it large? Small? How many lives would be saved if seat belt use increased from 52% to 90%?

f. There are two ways that mandatory seat belt laws are enforced: "Primary" enforce- ment means that a police officer can stop a car and ticket the driver if the officer observes an occupant not wearing a seat belt; "secondary" enforcement means that a police officer can write a ticket if an occupant is not wearing a seat belt, but must have another reason to stop the car. In the data set, primary is a binary variable for primary enforcement and secondary is a binary variable for secondary enforcement. Run a regression of sb_useage on primary, secondary, speed65, speed70, ba08, drinkage21, ln(income), and age, including fixed state and time effects in the regression. Does primary enforcement lead to more seat belt use? What about secondary enforcement?

g. In 2000, New Jersey changed from secondary enforcement to primary enforcement. Estimate the number of lives saved per year by making this change.

Reference no: EM131026338

Questions Cloud

What evidence exists in the practices of your school : What evidence exists in the practices of your school to support this position? Explain. To what degree and how are STEM principles addressed in non-STEM subjects in your school?
What is total ouput in the economy : What is total ouput in the economy? What is the wage rate in the economy? How much does an individual consume in the economy
Daily yields for the past week : A chemical process has produced, on the average, 800 tons of chemical per day. The daily yields for the past week are 785, 805, 790, 793, and 802 tons. Estimate the mean daily yield, with confidence coefficient .90, from the data. What assumptions..
Identify the sales trend over the period shown : Identify the sales trend over the period shown Do the demand figures show cyclical fluctuations? What happens on the sales trend if there is a prolong summer or a tragic incident like an earthquake or a flood.
Estimate the effect of seat belt use on fatalities : Are the OLS estimators consistent? Can confidence intervals be constructed in the usual way? If so, how do they differ from those that we would obtain if we had (measurement error free) observations on Yi? Explain.
Due to the economy and subsequent cuts in budget : Due to the economy and subsequent cuts in budget there has been a drastic reduction for many supplies deemed essential by the lab, suggest an approach to management to obtain greater funding.
Challenge for the trainer is ensuring the key messages : When training a group of workers, often the challenge for the trainer is ensuring the key messages are getting through to everyone. In larger groups it's not always easy keeping everyone engaged, and all too often, one or two of the workers are simpl..
What characteristic of leadership essential toward reform : Were there any biases or perspectives that needed to be overcome? Finally, what characteristics of leadership were essential toward such reform?
Estimate the fraction of the popular vote : How many voters must be included in a sample collected to estimate the fraction of the popular vote favorable to a presidential candidate in a national election if the estimate must be correct to within .005?

Reviews

Write a Review

Microeconomics Questions & Answers

  The free rider problem

Question: Explain why the free rider problem makes it difficult for perfectly competitive markets to provide the Pareto efficient level of a public good.

  Failure of the super committee is good thing for economy

Some commentators have argued that the failure of the “Super committee” is good thing for the economy?  Do you agree?

  Case study analysis about optimum resource allocation

Case study analysis about optimum resource allocation: -  Why might you suspect (even without evidence) that the economy might not be able to produce all the schools and clinics the Ministers want? What constraints are there on an economy's productio..

  Fixed cost and vairiable cost

Questions:  :   Which of the following are likely to be fixed costs and which variable costs for a chocolate factory over the course of a month?  Explain your choice.

  Problem - total cost, average cost, marginal cost

Problem - Total Cost, Average Cost, Marginal Cost: -  Complete the following table of costs for a firm.  (Note: enter the figures in the  MC   column  between  outputs of  0 and 1, 1 and 2, 2 and 3, etc.)

  Oligopoly and demand curve problem

Problem based on Oligopoly and demand curve,  Draw and explain the demand curve facing each firm, and given this demand curve, does this mean that firms in the jeans industry do or do not compete against one another?

  Impact of external costs on resource allocation

Explain the impact of external costs and external benefits on resource allocation;  Why are public goods not produced in sufficient quantities by private markets?  Which of the following are examples of public goods (or services)? Delete the incorrec..

  Shifts in demand and movements along the demand curve

Describe the differences between shifts in demand and movements along the demand curve. What are the main factors which can shift the demand curve? Explain why they cause the demand curve to shift. Use examples and draw graphs to support your discuss..

  Article review question

Article Review Question: Read the following excerpts from the article "Fruit, veg costs surge' by Todd, Dagwell, published in the Herald on January 25th 2011 and answer questions below:

  Long-term growth, international trade & globalization

Long-term Growth, International Trade & Globalization:- This question deals with concepts such as long-term growth, international trade and globalization. Questions related to trade deficit, trade surplus, gains from trade, an international trade sce..

  European monetary union (emu) in crisis

"Does the economic bailout of Spain and Greece spell the beginning of the end for the European Monetary Union (EMU)?"

  Development game “settlers of catan”

Read the rules of the game, the overview and the almanac for the Development Game "Settlers of Catan"

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd