Reference no: EM133817291
Assignment:
Step 1: Possible Objections
- Potential strain on public resources (education, healthcare)
- Concerns about national identity and cultural assimilation
- Risk of exploitation by undocumented immigrants
- Alternative solutions, such as deportation or strict border control
Step 2: Additional Evidence Needed - Long-term studies on economic and social impact
- Comparative analysis with other countries' immigration policies
- Expert testimony from law enforcement and national security officials
Step 3: Inductive Inferential Pattern Causal Argument: This pattern is appropriate for the argument since it seeks to show how establishing a road to citizenship affects social integration, economic development, and national security.
Step 4: Argument Map
P1: Social integration and employability are enhanced by education and career training.
P2: Integration of the immigrant workforce benefits labor-scarce industries.
P3: National security and public safety are guaranteed by background checks and tax compliance.
P4: Social measurements and economic indicators show effectiveness.
C: As a result, society gains from offering a route to citizenship via education, career training, and job requirements.