Drafting and ratification of the Constitution

Assignment Help History
Reference no: EM133456857

Question

The three authors whose works we have considered with respect to the drafting and ratification of the Constitution might be said to each have a different emphasis on why the Constitution came about and what it meant in terms of a continuous historical process. For her part, Carol Berkin seems to see the Constitution as a deviation from the revolutionary moment, a pragmatic response to changing conditions that required creative compromise. Francis Cogliano, on the other hand, seems to cast the Constitution as the culmination of the revolutionary process, the natural outcome of that process. Bailyn, however, calls the Constitution the "Fulfillment" of the ideology of revolution. Which of these characterizations-Deviation, Culmination, or Fulfillment-do you find to be the most persuasive way of understanding what the Constitution was and why it took the form it did?

Reference no: EM133456857

Questions Cloud

What disproportionate effects might there be on communities : How might the harm reduction approach affect substance use and misuse? What disproportionate effects might there be on communities?
What are main elements of Hip Hop : What are the main elements of Hip Hop? Name a popular Hip Hop artist from the founding years to present.
Difference between enslavement and indentured servitude : What is the difference between enslavement and indentured servitude?
Understand the diverse nature of the Congress : To understand the diverse nature of the 113th Congress, it is important to understand the basic characteristics of the members.
Drafting and ratification of the Constitution : The three authors whose works we have considered with respect to drafting and ratification of the Constitution might be said to each have a different emphasis
Research on size and capabilities of US Army and Navy : Research on the size and capabilities of the U.S. Army and Navy between 1798 and 1812.
Settle legal and moral issues through judiciary review : Analyze if the United States Supreme Court can settle legal and moral issues through judiciary review.
Langston hughes and the harlem renaissance : According to the Langston Hughes and the Harlem Renaissance video and the textbook, what was the Harlem Renaissance?
How did Cold War impact the United States policies : How did the Cold War impact the United States' policies and social movements during the Cold War?

Reviews

Write a Review

History Questions & Answers

  What background did your interviewee have on subject matter

What background did your interviewee have on the subject matter? What beliefs does your interviewee hold about the period that are true or untrue?

  Do you believe in freud theory that civilization was created

Do you believe in Freuds theory that civilization was created to temper aggression and that it has failed miserably at that goal? Why do you agree, or why not

  Are you hoping to see a new nation emerge

You are encouraged to be creative with the assignment, but make sure you are using facts from what you have read and learned to guide you.

  Discuss the ways in which societys stability contributed

HIS 120 Excelsior University Discuss the ways in which this society's stability contributed to the globalizing processes we saw this week, including trade

  Views on the role of government impact americans

Did his rhetoric match his the actions of the government? Were the results the same for all American families?

  Discuss the study of early western civilization

Find a site that is relevant to the study of early Western civilization. The topics may be taken from the pre-historical period through the Renaissance.

  Remian independent of foregin control during the cold war

Canada wanted to remian independent of foregin control during the cold war, but it also wanted to be a part of international decision making. How successful was Canada in achieving these objectives?

  Analyze the influence of interest groups on lawmaking

Research and analyze the influence of interest groups on lawmaking, using current news articles/political action committee websites.

  How does athens go from an oligarchy to a democracy

In Constitution of Athens Aristotle tells the story of the rise of Athenian democracy and the beginning of its decline. Describe the stages that Athens goes through in the process of arriving at democracy. How does Athens go from an oligarchy to..

  What factors contributed to the rise of the new right

What factors contributed to the rise of the new right? Explain the cultural developments and policy goals of the Reagan administration.

  Progressive era of the late 1800s

The United States went through dramatic economic change during and after the Civil War, as industrialization spread rapidly and changed society.

  When performing a gran stain on an unknown sample

When performing a Gran stain on an unknown sample, what is the best way to know if pink cells are truly Gram negative?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd