Does this argument meet its burden of proof

Reference no: EM13519664

Does this argument meet its burden of proof?

James Cox, an attorney to a Rendering factory that disposes of the spoiled leftovers from slaughterhouses, is being sued for damages by the local community. Cox describes the community organizers who complained about the smell in their neighborhood, as hyper-motivated complainants, who are suffering from hysteria. Cox describes the public reaction to the smells coming from the plant as unlikely to change with education; their collective reaction is a form mental illness. The smell is non-toxic, Cox, claims, and public reaction is out of proportion to the risks. Cox claims there is no way to determine to what extent people are imagining the smell. The school across the street from the factory claims it cannot open its windows, or let the children play outside, because the smell makes them gag. Homeowners claim their home values have dropped, now that the factory has located into their neighborhood.

Has Cox met his burden of proof?

Explain why or why not. Use the definition of burden of proof and the facts of this case to support your decision.

Reference no: EM13519664

Questions Cloud

Find the average angular velocity of his arms and legs : Biomedical measurements show that the arms and hands together typically make up 13.0 of a person's mass, while the legs and feet together account for 37.0. find the average angular velocity of his arms and legs

Obtain the tension in the wire : A tube 1.16 m long is closed at one end. A stretched wire is placed near the open end. The wire is 0.355 m long and has a mass of 8.80 g. Find the tension in the wire

Explain in detail socrates method of conducting philosophy : Explain in detail Socrates' method of conducting philosophy. Be specific. Give examples. Discuss at least two different approaches to ethics. Which approach, in general, do you believe is more successful at resolving ethical problem

Apparent irregularity in the motions of the planets : How does Copernicus resolve the puzzle about the apparent irregularity in the motions of the planets? What is the impact of a moving earth on Danteâs picture of the world? What does Kepler ass to the Copernicus picture? Contrast Aristotelian explanat..

Does this argument meet its burden of proof : James Cox, an attorney to a Rendering factory that disposes of the spoiled leftovers from slaughterhouses, is being sued for damages by the local community.

Substance-accident that you encounter in your everyday life : list what the substance is and what the accident is, for the substance, I want you to go on and explain what it is by describing the four causes of that thing. for the accident, state what substance that accident is associated with.

Briefly discuss the role of venereal disease : Briefly discuss the role of venereal disease in the discovery of the new world. How does this reinforce the satire in Candide?

What moral values or virtues are being pursued : Address the tension between a new humility and the desire to pursue utopian visions enabled by development. How should we respond to such visions? What moral values or virtues are being pursued?

Ties between social circumstances and technology : Do you think that the ties between social circumstances and technology, thoroughly discussed in the readings, should be a part of the definition of technology? Why or why not?

User Account

All Pages