Does the essay analyze and evaluate text not just summarize

Reference no: EM133639104

Assignment: Academic Review

Compose an academic book review for either:

Kashi, Ed. 2008. Curse of the Black Gold: 50 Years of Oil in the Niger Delta. powerHouse
Books: New York.

Grandia, Liza. 2012. Enclosed: Conservation, Cattle, and Commerce Among the Q'eqchi'
Maya Lowlanders. University of Washington Press: Seattle, WA.

The response should be 4-5 pages in length (1450 words)-Times New Roman, 1-inch margins, double-spaced. The analytical essay should be written as a reflective response to the prompt below. All opinions stated need to be supported by examples and all claims supported by evidence. This is a formal paper, meaning no personal pronouns, contractions or colloquialisms. This is social turbulence class.

An academic book review should identify and evaluate the author's thesis (i.e., does the author achieve the stated purpose of the book?), a brief summary of the argument, an analysis of the book's strengths and weaknesses. Common mistakes to avoid: do not just summarize, do not try to cover everything in the book (organize, synthesize, etc.), and do not use too many quotes. Judge the book by its intentions, not yours. In other words, do not criticize the author for not writing the book you think they should have written (you will have time in the discussion board for those types of comments).

Criteria for Evaluation

Question I. Is the stance/argument of the essay clearly stated?
Question II. Does the essay fully address the prompt?
Question III. Does the essay analyze and evaluate the text, not just summarize?
Question IV. Are the ideas and opinions introduced in the essay well formulated?
Question V. Is evidence is used to support all claims and opinions?
Question VI. Are the arguments presented in a clear and organized way?

Reference no: EM133639104

Questions Cloud

Discuss types of relationships that eleanor appears to have : Discuss the types of relationships that Eleanor appears to have. How does Eleanor embody or not embody the concepts of loneliness and social isolation?

Develop a profile form for family customers : Develop a profile form for family customers. What data will need to be collected on the Customer Profile Form?

How clearly stated is the research problem : How clearly stated is the research problem? Identify the research questions. Are they clearly stated and aligned to the problem?

How do you think current terms developed : How do you think current terms developed and why is this shift important? What about this content did you find to be of most interest?

Does the essay analyze and evaluate text not just summarize : Does the essay analyze and evaluate the text, not just summarize? Are the ideas and opinions introduced in the essay well formulated?

Give an introduction and conclusion to a speech : Give an introduction and conclusion to a speech you design (thus no guts). After thoroughly understanding chapters 9 and 10

Which you analyze your specific audience : Develop your full sentence speech and professional visual aid. Practice, practice, practice and create your speaking outline (an abbreviated speech

What are the benefits to engaging in an act of advocacy : Reflecting as a social worker, what are the benefits to engaging in an act of advocacy? Are there risks associated with being an advocate?

Examine the demographic transition : When countries moves from developing to developed nations they undergo both a demographic transition and an epidemiologic transition.

User Account

All Pages