Does the courts decision seem warranted

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM133470978

Question: A woman in her mid-thirties suffered from a rare malignancy in her brain and around her spinal cord. She had surgery, and most of the tumor mass was removed, but residual tumor remained in the brain and around the spinal cord. The doctors informed her that chemotherapy and radiation were possible treatment options but could cause serious problems such as sepsis, a permanent loss of IQ and stature, and even death. She wished to proceed with the therapy.

After undergoing aggressive chemotherapy and radiation, she did independent research and read of several drugs being administered for cancer in other states that were unapproved by the Federal Drug Administration (FDA) and were illegal in their home state but were touted by physicians using them as "miracle cures." The woman is considering suing her physician for failure to disclose alternative treatments, thus depriving her of informed consent.

A court awarded summary judgment to the physician.
Respond to the following questions about this case:

In your opinion, does the court's decision seem warranted? Why or why not?

Under the doctrine of informed consent, should a physician be responsible for informing patients of all treatment options, even if some of the treatments are illegal or not yet proven effective? Explain your answer.

Use APA formatting and citation standards. Use at least two (2) scholarly references published within the last 5 years to substantiate your work.

Reference no: EM133470978

Questions Cloud

Discuss the ethical challenges each of these components : Focusing on the police, courts, and corrections systems, discuss the ethical challenges each of these components in the criminal justice system face.
Identify any provisions or areas that you believe : Identify any provisions or areas that you believe should be included that are not addressed in this list of Patient's Rights
Distinguish between the terms actus reus and mens rea : Distinguish between the terms actus reus and mens rea. How are they significant in criminal law? - what standard of law must the defendant's mens rea be proven
Discuss medical records and importance of confidentiality : Discuss medical records and the importance of confidentiality and Describe one legal standard, regulation, or policy that is related to confidentiality
Does the courts decision seem warranted : Does the courts decision seem warranted? Why or why not - should a physician be responsible for informing patients of all treatment options
Define liability and malpractice : Define liability and malpractice and Summarize the three areas of general liability for which a physician/employer is responsible
What are two major setbacks or shortcomings of the ucr : What are two major setbacks or shortcomings of the UCR? Also, what do you understand by “The Face Page of a Report.? "Criminal Justice"
Why is it important for building effective provider : Why Is It Important For Building Effective Provider/Patient Relationships And Maintaining A Standard Of Care
Explain the legal term voir dire, its origins : Explain the legal term voir dire, its origins, and its purposes. - Detail the process of voir dire, and distinguish between peremptory and discretionary strikes

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Prison system

Inmates have sued the prison system for items like the color of the paint on the walls.

  Discuss about the several levels of proceedings

After a person is arrested, they go through several levels of proceedings before a case is adjudicated. These phases are: Arraignment.

  Executive branch failure to implement or enforce laws

What about court action to enforce executive branch failure to implement or enforce laws?

  Conception of the human mind as a blank slate

In "Phaedo," Plato gives an early argument against the conception of the human mind as a blank slate. He argues that when we learn something we are recollecting the knowledge we gained before we were born.

  What screening tools you would use to assess knowledge

Identify what screening tools you would use to assess nutritional and exercise knowledge, and why? One Outcome/Intervention/Rationale.

  Find criminal case-book of nonfiction or fiction

Find a criminal case, a book of nonfiction or fiction, a short story, news article, or a movie from the past 10 years,

  How does an organization proactively approach

How does an organization proactively approach and respond to social responsibility/ sustainability?

  Identify sociological concepts that affect field of study

Identify sociological concepts that affect one's own field of study. Identify resources to support project analysis from a sociological perspective.

  What evidence points in opposite direction of your position

What evidence would you to point to in support your conclusion? What evidence points in the opposite direction of your position?

  Describe are you more hobbs or more rousseau

Describe in briefly about: are you more Hobbs or more Rousseau? Or are you somewhere in between? Explain why and how these beliefs impact your views of the law.

  Why is planning important in marketing

Why is planning important in marketing? What are the essential components of a marketing plan? How would you convince your supervisor that the marketing department should produce formal marketing plans?

  Examine best practices for relationship building

Union membership percentages have declined dramatically in the last century, though there are still thousands of employees and businesses that struggle to be.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd