Does it matter to the out-come of this dispute explain

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133193507 , Length: 2 pages

Case: Assume that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has a rule under which it enforces statutory provisions prohibiting insider trading only when the insiders make monetary profits for themselves. Then the SEC makes a new rule, declaring that it has the statutory authority to bring enforcement actions against individuals even if they did not personally profit from the insider trading. The SEC simply announces the new rule without conducting a rulemaking proceeding. A stockbrokerage firm objects and says that the new rule was unlawfully developed without opportunity for public comment. The brokerage firm challenges the rule in an action that ultimately is reviewed by a federal appellate court. Using the information presented in the chapter, answer the following questions.

Question 1: Is the SEC an executive agency or an independent regulatory agency? Does it matter to the out-come of this dispute? Explain.

Question 2: Suppose that the SEC asserts that it has always had the statutory authority to pursue persons for insider trading regardless of whether they personally profited from the transaction. This is the only argument the SEC makes to justify changing its enforcement rules.

Question 3: Would a court be likely to find that the SEC's action was arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA)? Why or why not?

Question 4: Would a court be likely to give Chevron deference to the SEC's interpretation of the law on insider trading? Why or why not?

Now assume that a court finds that the new rule is merely "interpretive." What effect would this determination have on whether the SEC had to follow the APA's rulemaking procedures?

Reference no: EM133193507

Questions Cloud

Can superior meet these requirements : Florida International University - Determine accountants' liability to third parties, could Chase be liable to Superior? Explain

How can social workers advocate for social change : How can Social Workers advocate for social change to reduce environmental challenges for the homeless IN SINGAPORE?

Analyzing the moral dilemmas : There are many different moral theories, each of which provides a different way of analyzing the moral dilemmas we face in our lives.

Discuss people responsibility as relates to health outcome : Question - Discuss people responsibility as it relates to health outcome. Address how socioeconomic factors might impact an individual's ability to be held

Does it matter to the out-come of this dispute explain : The brokerage firm challenges the rule in an action that ultimately is reviewed by a federal appellate court - SEC's interpretation of the law on insider

Write an explanation of personal action plans you might take : Write an explanation of personal action plans you might take to address engagement in your field education experience.

Behavior of people-businesses reduce nitrates in blue spring : Assignment Task: Should government agencies regulate the behavior of people and businesses to reduce nitrates in Blue Spring?

Analyze four concerns that the family is facing : As the professional social worker assigned to support the family, outline and analyze FOUR concerns that the family is facing.

Evaluate descriptive statistics for data : There is often the requirement to evaluate descriptive statistics for data within the organization or for health care information

User Account

All Pages