Does given case belong in the us supreme court

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131378411

The state of Alabama was required under the provisions of its own constitution to reapportion its electoral districts every 10 years. However, the state had failed to reapportion districts for more than half a century.

Since then, the population of Alabama had grown to such an extent that severe inequalities existed among the electoral districts. The inequalities were so great in some cases that the votes of citizens in some parts of the state carried as much as 10 times the weight of the votes of citizens in other parts of the state.

A suit was brought in federal court on the grounds that the inequalities in voting power violated certain guarantees found in the U.S. Constitution. The defendants argued that the federal court should not interfere in what is essentially a state matter and that by doing so, it would upset the delicate balance between the states and the federal government.

Nevertheless, the federal district court struck down the apportionment scheme as unconstitutional. Does this case belong in the U.S. Supreme Court? Explain the reasons for your response. Should the Supreme Court uphold or overturn the federal district court's decision? Explain.

Reynolds v. Sims, 377 U.S. 533 (U.S. Sup. Ct.).

Reference no: EM131378411

Questions Cloud

Discuss topic of heredity and crime : Discuss topic of heredity and crime. What does the research show? What are some of the weaknesses of the research in this area? Discuss the topic of chromosomes, genes, and crime. What does the research show? What are some of the weaknes..

History pose a potential risk for complications : In the following three case scenarios, determine if the patient has an increased risk for surgical complications based on their current health status and medical history.

Compare the two standardized assessments you selected : Review the article, "Offender Risk Assessment." Focus on the specific risk assessment tests that are frequently used to predict crime and violence. Think about the strengths and limitations of these tools to predict criminal behavior and classify..

What each summary tells us about the motion picture industry : Tabular and graphical summaries for each of the four variables along with a discussion of what each summary tells us about the motion picture industry.

Does given case belong in the us supreme court : Does this case belong in the U.S. Supreme Court? Explain the reasons for your response. Should the Supreme Court uphold or overturn the federal district court's decision? Explain.

How do businesses create a successful corporate culture : How do businesses create a successful corporate culture? If you're interested in exploring high employee motivation and loyalty, prepare a report on corporate culture. Corporate culture is the synthesis of an organization's collective beliefs, val..

Explain the social inequalities related to this social issue : This milestone is a concept map that will help you visualize the social issue and how it relates to the following sociological concepts: cultural beliefs and biases, social roles, social inequalities, and existing social conditions. A concept map ..

Is the government of sudan correct in given case : The argument was based on the fact that the case involved citizens of states of the United States in an attempt to sue a foreign government, something not permitted under federal law. Is the government of Sudan correct in this case? Explain.

Should supreme court uphold the appellate courts decision : Should the supreme court uphold the appellate court's decision? What standard of review should be involved here? Explain.

User Account

All Pages