Does aquinas proof in any way suffer for his not being

Reference no: EM133441958

Questions: We can inquire as to whether the Being proved by Aquinas in proof 3 might be the universe itself. In proof 5 he implicitly eliminates this possibility by proving the existence of a Being who is both intelligent and purposeful. I nevertheless find it puzzling that Aquinas refers to the possibility of multiple necessary Beings near the end of proof 3. This would seem to compromise monotheism.

In both proofs 1 and 2 the conclusions are based on the shared assumption between Aquinas and his readers that infinite regress is impossible. Interestingly then there is a minority position in contemporary epistemology (philosophy of knowledge) that endorses infinite regress as a strategy for justifying our basic beliefs.

In proof 1 Aquinas refers to motion in general. Following Aristotle, what he really means is change - which includes motion as a displacement in space in our customary sense. Four centuries later, Newton distinguished between rest/uniform motion and accelerated motion. There is no physical difference between an object at rest and an object in constant or uniform motion (no change in velocity or direction). Does Aquinas' proof in any way suffer for his not being aware of this fact about motion?

Reference no: EM133441958

Questions Cloud

How do you know if what happen last year actually occurred : How do you know if what happen last year actually occurred? Could there be any doubt it happen as you remember? Consider Descartes argument, and incorporate it

What was the change and how was it implemented : Was it an effective change? How? If the change was not effective, then could you think of an innovative solution that could have resulted in a better outcome

How difficult would it be for you to work with : How difficult would it be for you to work with a developmentally disabled individual? What challenges do you think you might face and how would you address

Is rosseau critique of economic equality is true : is Rousseau's critique of economic equality is still relevant in today's society since it provides an important reminder of the need to generate a more

Does aquinas proof in any way suffer for his not being : which includes motion as a displacement in space in our customary sense. Four centuries later, Newton distinguished between rest/uniform motion and accelerated

Describe at least one effective study strategies : Describe at least one effective study strategies that you could incorporate into your studying moving forward. How will you do it

Where was this found information : Where was this found information? Please include an in-text citation and evidence ! The Battle of Hastings, which resulted in the defeat of the Anglo-Saxon Rule

What is morality based on for virtue ethics : What is morality based on for virtue ethics? What exactly is moral virtue? How is moral virtue developed, and and in what way is virtue a mean?

Are they incompatible, but interesting to juxtapose or mix : Are they incompatible, but interesting to juxtapose or mix?" "Or, at the other extreme, are they fundamentally the same activity, and it's the business of art

User Account

All Pages