Do you think is most just way of allocating military service

Reference no: EM133342349

Assignment:

During the US Civil War, the Union army needed soldiers.

And so Congress enacted a draft conducted by lottery.

But the draft had an unusual provision.

Those who were conscripted had a choice.

If you didn't want to fight in the Civil War and if you had enough money, you could hire a substitute to take your place.

These days, the U.S., like most countries, has an all-volunteer army of paid soldiers.

No one is conscripted.

Some people argue it is more just to recruit soldiers by paying them then by conscripting them.

Others argue that using the market to decide who will fight our wars, whether in the Civil War way or in the way of the all-volunteer army, unfairly allows the affluent to buy their way out of military service.

What do you think is the most just way of allocating military service?

Conscription by lottery with no buyout provision?

Conscription by lottery with a buyout provision, as in the Civil War?

Or an all-volunteer system where the market decides who will fight our wars?

Reference no: EM133342349

Questions Cloud

Describe the fruit-of-the-poisonous-tree doctrine : Describe the "fruit-of-the-poisonous-tree" doctrine. Is it an effective tool to control illegal law enforcement tactics? Why or why not?

How would implement change in criminal justice organization : How would you implement change in a criminal justice organization? How would you show or tell your personnel for changes in the organization?

Discuss an ethical-security breach that involves equifax : Your textbook discusses an ethical and security breach that involves Equifax. What was the communication issue involving Equifax and the consumers?

Discussing delinquents are of the chronic variety : Imagine that you are in charge of policy at a juvenile detention center. You only have limited room and have to release some delinquents.

Do you think is most just way of allocating military service : What do you think is the most just way of allocating military service? Conscription by lottery with no buyout provision?

Discuss about juvenile waiver from both the text : Referencing what you have learned about juvenile waiver from both the text and from your reading of Kent v US, what are the presumed benefits.

Describe the government social program is administered : Describe how government social program is administered and answer the following: What monitoring techniques or steps are in place to detect or prevent fraud?

What do you already know about juvenile sex laws : What do you already know about juvenile sex laws? - the offenders- why do they offend-who are usually the victims? do they usually report?

Describe processes of legislative-judicial decision making : That legal realism best describes the processes of both legislative and judicial decision making. Discuss. From Canadian Law: An Introduction, 7th Edition.

User Account

All Pages