Do you kill the one innocent patient to save the lives

Reference no: EM131831005

a. The "trolley problem" is a famous ethical puzzle created by Philippa Foot: You are the conductor of a trolley (or subway or streetcar or train) that is heading out of control down a track.

Five innocent people are tied to the track ahead of you: If you run over them, they will surely die. If you push a lever on your trolley, it will shift onto another track, where one unfortunate person is tied up. Either you let five people die or you choose to kill one person:

Those are your only choices. Which will you choose and why? Which ethical view from this chapter best fits your reasoning? (If you Google "trolley problem," you will find many other interesting ethical dilemmas to debate with your friends.)

b. Another ethical dilemma sounds quite different: You are a medical doctor trying to find five organ donors to save the lives of five innocent people.

A new patient comes in for a checkup, and you find that this patient has five organs exactly compatible with the five innocent people. Do you kill the one innocent patient to save the lives of five innocents?

Suppose you will never get caught: Perhaps you live in a country where people don't care about such things. Is this the same dilemma? Is it the same dilemma from a utilitarian perspective?

Reference no: EM131831005

Questions Cloud

How could you write the design matrix : How could you write the design matrix for a 28 factorial design? How many rows would it have? How many columns? How would you randomize this design?

Comment on the possible implications of results : The purpose of these four trials was to discover the effects of" these two alloying elements (nickel and manganese) on the breaking strength of a certain

What is the significance of the given trend : Some of newer protocols, such as IPv6, are not including any kind of error-detection scheme on data portion of packet. What is the significance of this trend?

Is there a good way of distinguishing between the two : Which of the following issues were considered things that should be left to individuals and which were things that should be put up for a vote?

Do you kill the one innocent patient to save the lives : Another ethical dilemma sounds quite different: You are a medical doctor trying to find five organ donors to save the lives of five innocent people.

Anova of a randomized block design : What are its possible shortcomings? How can diagnostic checks be made to detect possible inadequacies in the model?

How many bits are needed to specify the register : A digital computer has a memory unit with 32 bits per word. How many bits are needed to specify the register? How many bits are needed for the opcode

Interest obtained from the anova approach : Show its essential equivalence to the paired t test. IS every aspect of possible interest obtained from the ANOVA approach?

How could a person reasonably justify a ban on gambling : What do you think best describes the reason that trade in recreational drugs is illegal: fear of exploitation, meddlesome preferences, notions of fairness.

User Account

All Pages