Do you agree with the courts decision in jacobson

Reference no: EM133499886

Question: The Tenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution declares that "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people." One of the powers not delegated to the federal government is the police power. As outlined in Chapter 2 of your text, this power is commonly used by a state to regulate the health and welfare of the people within its jurisdiction.

An example of this police power can be seen in the case Jacobson v. Massachusetts. In 1902, the city of Cambridge, Massachusetts, adopted a regulation requiring all inhabitants of the city to be vaccinated, or revaccinated, against the smallpox virus. A resident of Cambridge, Henning Jacobson, refused vaccination and was prosecuted and fined. Jacobson appealed the decision to the United States Supreme Court.

In 1905, the United States Supreme Court ruled, in a 7-2 decision, against Jacobson, holding that a state, utilizing its authority under its police power, could require healthy adults to be vaccinated in the interests of the "common good."

Do you agree with the court's decision in Jacobson? Why or why not?

Considering the concept of federalism, what role, if any, does the Tenth Amendment play in defining the powers of federal and state governments? use citations

Reference no: EM133499886

Questions Cloud

Why we talk about these standards in relation : why we talk about these standards in relation to addressing public health problems, and not to go through the standards themselves

Examine interactions between ancient persia and greek city : Examine the interactions between ancient Persia and the Greek city-states during the Persian Wars.

Describe the role congress and the epa played : Describe the role Congress and the EPA played in addressing the environmental crisis of acid rain. Was the action taken by Congress and the EPA successful

What are things you can do to have more positive perception : What are three things you can do to have a more positive perception of yourself and life situations? How can resilience help us overcome adverse life situation?

Do you agree with the courts decision in jacobson : what role, if any, does the Tenth Amendment play in defining the powers of federal and state governments? use citations

Explain right of entry as it applies to the fire official : Explain right of entry as it applies to the fire official. As a part of your explanation, compare and contrast the permit model and inspection model

Describes conservative values as well as social conditions : Describes the conservative values as well as the social and economic conditions that he believes led a majority of people living in rural America to vote.

Where you went to high school what are your career plans : Where you went to high school? What are your career plans or major? What is your favorite food? What is unique about you? Why are you taking this class

Identify defenses on petito civil complaints : Identify defenses on Petito Civil Complaints that could be asserted against the Petito family's negligence claim and what is the likelihood of each defense

User Account

All Pages