Do you agree with the court that such a rule is needed

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM13790306

Assignment: The Exclusionary Rule

In 1961, the US Supreme Court rendered its decision in Mapp v. Ohio. The case involved an unlawful, warrantless search of Dollree Mapp's apartment by the police looking for a fugitive. During the search, the police came across illegal pornography and charged Mapp with the possession of obscene materials. The US Supreme Court reversed Mapp's conviction.

The most significant result of this decision was the formation of the "exclusionary rule" for state prosecutions. At the time, the new rule certainly had an impact on US policing, as exemplified in the New York City Police Department (NYPD). In the year prior to the Mapp case, the NYPD had not secured a single search warrant. In the year after the Mapp case, the NYPD secured and executed over seven hundred search warrants. The number of secured search warrants rapidly increased in the coming years. But the rule continues to be controversial.

What is the exclusionary rule, and what was the court's purpose in creating it?
Do you agree with the court that such a rule is needed?
Is the exclusionary rule still relevant in light of the deterrent of civil liability for police officers?
If so, should there be exceptions to the use of this rule? If it is not needed, should laws be passed to bar the courts from using it? Explain and justify your response.

Reference no: EM13790306

Questions Cloud

Nexus between narcotics mafia and the terrorist groups : Do organized crime and the nexus between narcotics mafia and the terrorist groups in Mexico pose a danger to our nation's security? Why

Environment and patient care delivery issues : What are the underlying assumptions, values, and beliefs of the particular theory or model that you have chosen?

Example of a primary market transaction : 2) An example of a primary market transaction is

Predetermined rate was based on a cost formula : Westan Corporation uses a predetermined overhead rate of $22.30 per direct labor-hour. This predetermined rate was based on a cost formula that estimated $267,600 of total manufacturing overhead for an estimated activity level of 12,000 direct labor-..

Do you agree with the court that such a rule is needed : What is the exclusionary rule, and what was the court's purpose in creating it? Do you agree with the court that such a rule is needed? Is the exclusionary rule still relevant in light of the deterrent of civil liability for police officers

Difference between direct materials and direct labor : What is the difference between direct materials and direct labor? What is manufacturing overhead?

Exceptions to the hearsay rule of confessions : Discuss in detail the exceptions to the hearsay rule of confessions, admissions, spontaneous and excited utterance, dying declaration and former testimony. Identify one of the Saint Leo Core values and apply it to the discussion

Any federal self-employment tax implications : John Smith, age 31, is single and has no dependents. At the beginning of 2014, John started his own excavation business and named it Earth Movers. John lives at 1045 Center Street, Lindon, UT, and his business is located at 381 State Street, Lindon, ..

Describe and discuss visible street robberies : Describe and discuss visible street robberies. Describe and discuss when purse snatching becomes a robbery. Identify one of the Saint Leo Core values and apply it to the discussion

User Account

All Pages