Do we really have a moral obligation never to tell a lie

Reference no: EM133221672

Assignment - Philosophy Kantian Deontology Discussion

Respond to this prompt - A student once said to me after class: "so Kant would have been a vocal abolitionist but he still would have ratted out Harriet Tubman." The question she was raising was: Do we really have a moral obligation never to tell a lie? While we can all recognize the benefits of dealing honestly with one another, we have to look at some of the potential unintended consequences of total honesty. For example, would the duty not to lie extend to a scenario in which a murderer asks you for the whereabouts of his intended victim? Wouldn't answering honestly (assuming you knew the victim's location) make you at least partially responsible for the murder?

One of the main criticisms of Kant's moral theory is that total adherence to moral duty is far too rigid in the sense that it fails to take in the totality of the particular circumstances in a situation, and could very well lead to the scenario I outlined in another post about where one must decide whether or not to disclose to an ax-wielding murderer the whereabouts of his intended victim on the grounds that one must never tell a lie. I'd like to hear what the rest of you think about this.

Reference no: EM133221672

Questions Cloud

What is a pareto front : 1. What are the two objectives that you usually want to achieve when trying to buy a phone?

Calculate the price elasticity of demand : A surge of 60% in gasoline prices resulted in a decline in the purchase of gasoline by 15%. Calculate the price elasticity of demand

Conducting performance evaluations for plant managers : You are the Director of Manufacturing and are conducting performance evaluations for your Plant Managers. ?Using the template provided complete the performance

Have johnny and ash formed a partnership : Johnny and Ash have not yet incorporated their new company. However, each has already invested $50 000 into the business by depositing the money into Johnny's b

Do we really have a moral obligation never to tell a lie : Do we really have a moral obligation never to tell a lie? While we can all recognize the benefits of dealing honestly with one another

Explain a situation that happened to you : 1. Explain a situation that happened to you, and how would you have handled it differently based on the outcome and what would you change when faced with a simi

Six common project time and cost management challenges : Identify six common project time and cost management challenges (three each for time and cost management), and describe how an effective time and cost managemen

Discuss model for assessing the successful design : In their article, Poister and Streib (2005) discuss one "model for assessing the successful design and implementation of a strategic management capacity in a go

Ted talk inside the mind of a master procrastinator : Please solve all of the questions with the instructions below and thank you so much sir.

User Account

All Pages