Do the gods love what is morally right because

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133528084

Case: In Plato's Euthyphro, the two main characters debate an eponymous question. Euthyphro says that "piety is what all the gods love, and piety is what they all hate." Remember that, translated into our terms, this statement would mean "moral rightness is what all the gods love, and moral wrongness is what all the gods hate." In response, Socrates asks a question (that demonstrates the main philosophical problem with Divine command theory): "Do the gods love what is morally right because it is morally right, or is it right because they love it?"

Explain the issue at hand, including the meaning and importance of this question, (b) explain and critically discuss how Socrates uses this question to cast doubt on Euthyphro's thesis that morality does depend on religion, and(c) explain and critically discuss what this question entails (means) for any person who maintains that God is the origin or foundation of morality.

Reference no: EM133528084

Questions Cloud

Describe what you learned about working with the population : Describe the population which you are interested in working with. (ELDERLY). Describe what you learned about working with this population.

Role of parents in enhancing the self-esteem : To this point in the course we have discussed the role of parents in enhancing the self-esteem of their children.

What is the presupposition that we take for granted : What is the presupposition that we take for granted in our everyday, commensensical theory (or we could say 'view' or 'explanation') of moral responsibility

Explain the pathophysiology of coeliacs disease : Explain the pathophysiology of coeliacs disease. What sort of diet would you need to ensure Sally has? How would you weigh and measure Sally accurately?

Do the gods love what is morally right because : Explain and critically discuss what this question entails (means) for any person who maintains that God is the origin or foundation of morality

Would you consider this case workplace bullying : Would you consider this case workplace bullying? Why or why not? What type of counterproductive work behaviors can you identify in this case?

Apply the concept of moral equivalence : Apply the concept of moral equivalence. Is the conduct of doctors in relation to smoking and the tobacco industry morally equivalent to the conduct of doctors

Who would you report your concerns to about george : Who would you report your concerns to about George? Which members of the allied health team would you approach to address the issues George has raised?

Is the greater divide created out of gender : is the greater divide created out of gender difference or sociology, nature or nurture? based on gender rolls and care ethics

User Account

All Pages