Do paper make contribution to body of scientific literature

Assignment Help Business Economics
Reference no: EM13964681

Economic history referee report "BUSINESS FAILURES BY INDUSTRY IN THE UNITED STATES, 1895 TO 1939: A STATISTICAL HISTORY.".

(each report being 2 ½ to 4 single spaced pages in length-one inch margins on each side and no larger than 12-point font)

1. supposed to be criticed and raise question and also provide suggestions for improvement (talk about what should be done)

2. a. a brief synopisis(tell the editor whether you understand the paper)

b. overall assessment ( one or two paragraph, how you view the paper)

c. area of concern, issue to address, linger questions

d. small part

b. overall assessment

-was the paper well written -was the paper original - was the paper well motivated -did the paper make clear what it was about, what question it was asking, how it was going to answer it.

Originality -does this paper make a contribution to body of scientific literature -does it tell us sth didnt know before -learn sth?
Motivation---is this paper answer question that people care about ---use ur own judgement
Clarity---does paper do what it said it would do ---can you follow?

c. area, issues

-75%of the paper ---show what you know ---one of first issueis theory (is appropriate or not)
History-2nd area

--does the paper get history right?

large part- showing that you knwo the literature author talking

Data and methodology

--is data appropriate ---is indirect ot direct method? ----if direct, is the data can be trusted?----if indirect, is the data can be trusted?

Reference no: EM13964681

Questions Cloud

Special cargo categories-hazardous goods-fragile cargo : Research and write about three of the 5 special cargo categories (Hazardous goods, Fragile Cargo, Outsized Cargo, Perishable Cargo and High Value Cargo). Include information on:
The boys who participate in athletics are taller than other : A random sample has mean height of 80 boys, who participated in the athletic competition was 167 cm with a standard deviation of 9 cm. The mean height of the 160 boys who did not participate in the athletic competition was 163 cm with a standard devi..
Develop a point estimate of the price for a sleeping bag : Data on x = temperature rating (F°) and y = price ($) for 11 sleeping bags manufactured by Bergans of Norway provided the estimated regression equation ÿ = 359.2668 - 5.2772x. For these data s = 37.9372.
Assume that the company uses absorption costing : Assume that the company uses absorption costing:a. Compute the unit product cost. b. Prepare an income statement for the year.
Do paper make contribution to body of scientific literature : Originality -does this paper make a contribution to body of scientific literature -does it tell us sth didnt know before -learn sth?
Enough evidence to support the claim : The Pew Research Center claims that more than 55% of American adults regularly watch a network news broadcast. You decide to test this claim and ask a random sample of 425 Americans whether they regularly watch a network news broadcast. Of the 425 Am..
Company claim that the mean life and standard deviation : A company claim that the mean life and standard deviation of the bulbs are 360 hours and 90 hours respectively. A sample of 625 bulbs is chosen. It is found that the mean life and standard deviation of the bulb in the sample are 355 hour and 90 hours..
Moon is considering two options to increase its capacity : Moon Micro is a small make- to order manufacturer of servers that currently builds its entire product in Santa Clara, California. The current demand and capacity are 10,000 servers per year. The annualized fixed cost is $15,000,000. As the market for..
Find the pressure if the temperature i increased to 500 c. : At a temperature of 20 C, how many kilomoles can be withdrawn from the tank before the pressure falls to 10% of the original pressure?

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Economics Questions & Answers

  Economics assignment

This document contains various important questions and their appropriate answers in the subject field of Economics.

  Demand and supply curves

Economics is the study of the principles governing the allocation of scarce means among competing ends when the objective of the allocation is to maximize the attainment of the ends.

  Long-run perfectly competitive equilibrium for the firm

Evaluate Government intervene and correct this situation?(a) Explain the concept of a concentration ratio. A rise in the price of magarine Explain the impact of external costs and external benefits on resource allocation long-run perfectly c..

  Supply and demand diagrams

Explain each of the following using supply and demand diagrams,  With the use of a graph, explain how these two programs affect cigarette consumption and the price of cigarettes.

  Case study: fisher-price toys

The case study of the Fisher-Price Toys, Inc., a popular case in basic economics and management from the prestigious Harvard Business School.

  Draw the production possibility curve

Draw the production possibility curve and a. Define consumer surplus and producer surplus.

  Tax revenue

The Australian government administers two programs that affect the market for cigarettes

  Maximize total welfare

How many tickets to sell to maximize total welfare.

  Difference between the cv and the ev

The change in consumer surplus (?CS) is not "theoretically" justifiable like the CV and EV but it continues to be the most widely used measure of consumer welfare change. Explain how this can be reconciled

  Depict von neumann-morgenstern utility index u in a diagram

Depict the von Neumann-Morgenstern utility index u in a diagram

  What is the market solution

What is the market solution (market price and quantity) and What is the total surplus of the society under the market solution

  Calculate gross national product and net national product

Calculate gross national product and net national product

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd