Discussion - Burwell v Hobby Lobby Stores Case

Reference no: EM132512138

Assignment - The basis for this forum discussion is the U.S. Supreme Court case of Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., also the subject of your Case Brief Assignment.

This case is about a business'' leadership making real business decisions about employer-provided employee health care benefits. This decision violated a government mandate that private for-profit businesses provide certain types of birth control benefits. The company, Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., took a stand against the government's position, based on the business ownership's religious beliefs, raising a Constitutional question under the First Amendment.

In addition to the Hobby Lobby case itself, please consider, in particular, the Horwitz article listed in your Required Readings in Lessons, as well as other research on the subject, to inform your own thoughts on the following points. And discuss in a narrative post. Please do not simply list "questions and answers." Address these questions within an essay format.

What are the constitutional implications on business exemplified by this case? How was the 1st Amendment involved? How was the government violating Hobby Lobby's 1st Amendment right, according to the U.S. Supreme Court?

Hobby Lobby Stores. Inc. is a family owned business, described as "closely held." What does this mean, i.e., what is a closely held corporation? Did this make a difference in the court's consideration of Hobby Lobby's 1st Amendment religious freedom argument? Would the same argument work for a large publicly held corporation like IBM? Should it? Why or why not? What are the social and political interests in play that the Court endeavored to balance in the legal setting?

Should a business be able to invoke the 1st Amendment protection at all on the basis of the business owner(s)' personal beliefs as human beings? Why or why not? If the business is a separate person, as the Court has held in finding that the business has an independent Constitutional right, how can this "corporate person," as an entity, manifest an independent religious belief? (For this question you might want to also take a look at the Supreme Court's opinion in the Citizens United case.

Please clearly and thoroughly discuss these points in a well-organized post. Your text and other required readings and research should form a foundation for your discussion. At a minimum your thoughts should be informed by the court's opinion in Hobby Lobby, the Horwitz article, and your textbook readings. You may have other ideas -- research further to support them. We invite and expect respectful debate in the forum discussions. Enjoy the challenge!

Required Reading - Mayer, D., Warner, D., Siedel, G. Lieberman, J., & Martina, A. (n.d.) Business law and the legal environment. Washington, D. C.: Saylor Foundation.

Chapter 4: Constitutional Law and US Commerce

Chapter 6: Criminal Law

Chapter 7: Introduction to Tort Law

Chapter 31: Introduction to Property: Personal Property and Fixtures

Reading for Forum and Assignment 2: Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., 573 U.S. 682 (2014).

Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 130 S.Ct. (2010).

Horwitz, P. (2014). The Hobby Lobby moment. Harv. L. Rev. 128, 154-189.

Attachment:- Assignment File - Case Study.rar

Reference no: EM132512138

Questions Cloud

Distinguish between structural unemployment : Distinguish between "Structural unemployment" and "cyclical (demand deficiency) unemployment"

What is the net investment cash outflow for the project : What is the project-disposal cash flow (not including the annual operating cash flow)? What is the operating cash flow for the 3rd year of the project's life?

Find the optimal pigovian tax needed to correct the external : Abel shares an apartment with Tim. Abel drinks alcohol while Tim hates drinking. The utility functions for Abel (A) and Tim (T) are as follows:

Manufactures computer equipment : As the managing director for your company, based in India, that manufactures computer equipment, you are negotiating with an official in China.

Discussion - Burwell v Hobby Lobby Stores Case : The basis for this forum discussion is the U.S. Supreme Court case of Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., also the subject of your Case Brief Assignment

Same standard of living in seattle : In order to have the same standard of living in Seattle, you would need to earn how much money? (Note: Round this to the nearest dollar.)

Modern public corporation : What are its distinguishing characteristics? How is the "modern public corporation" different from older forms of corporations?

Motivation affect thomas level of managerial hubris : The 1920 Farrow's Bank failure: case of managerial hubris. How did corporate culture, leadership, power-motivation affect Thomas' level of managerial hubris?

Describe characteristics of fiscal policy in great recession : Describe the characteristics of fiscal policy in the Great Recession.

User Account

All Pages