Discussing sikhism potential origin as hindu sect

Reference no: EM133598279

Question

As detailed in the textbook, Professor Harjot Oberoi was forced out of his endowed chair in Sikh Studies at the University of British Columbia by Sikhs angry that his book The Construction of Religious Boundaries (1994) emphasized a history of fluid Hindu/Sikh boundaries. Who gets to decide what is appropriate or inappropriate academic scholarship--practitioners or trained historians? Was Oberoi, who is a Sikh, disrespectful to the Sikh community by discussing Sikhism's potential origin as a Hindu sect? Or was the conservative Sikh backlash impinging on academic freedom?

Reference no: EM133598279

Questions Cloud

Why does wegman approach to compensation seem to work : Why does Wegman's approach to compensation seem to work so well? Why don't other grocery chains use the same compensation model as Wegmans?

What is contemporary american conservatism and liberalism : What is contemporary American conservatism and liberalism. Include in your answer the social and economic dimensions (or sections) of these two ideologies.

What barriers might exist for an organisation, structured : What barriers might exist for an organisation, structured as a bureaucracy, to be able to adapt to strong 'winds of change' blowing from its environment?

What methods were used to test the hypothesis : What was the hypothesis? What methods were used to test the hypothesis? Provide an analysis of the ethical considerations of the study.

Discussing sikhism potential origin as hindu sect : who is a Sikh, disrespectful to the Sikh community by discussing Sikhism's potential origin as a Hindu sect?

What failures were present in the case that led to failures : Who were the key stakeholders involved in this case? Was this a regulation failure or a market failure? Could this situation have been prevented from occurring

What are all the functions of hrm within an organization : What are all the functions of HRM within an organization. Is it important for a successful company to have dedicated HR staff or can an administrative person

Assume that there are no transaction costs for negotiation : Assume that there are no transaction costs for negotiation. Will the parties negotiate and reach an agreement for factory to install the scrubber?

What is the public opinion of the corporation process : What is the public opinion of the corporation's process or production, and relationship with its employees and Americans, what is the public opinion?

User Account

All Pages