Discuss the wives of the guardians of his ideal city

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133484822

Assignment:

In the first few pages of Book V of Plato's Republic, Socrates is discussing the role that women will play as "wives" of the guardians of his ideal city. During the discussion, Socrates implies that his discussion concerning the tasks assigned to female guardians seems to contradict what has already been agreed upon as the method for assigning tasks in general. This apparent contradiction is stated clearly at 453b&e. carefully explain what this apparent contradiction is - how, exactly, does it seem that Socrates and his friends are contradicting themselves? What have they said and/or agreed upon seems to contradict?

Next, you are to explain how Socrates believes this apparent contradiction has arisen - what error or oversight has been committed, that has led to this apparent contradiction? Finally, explain how Socrates clarifies his analysis, and demonstrates that, upon a more clear and careful examination, there is in fact no contradiction at all. This discussion takes place from approximately 454a - 456c.

Use ordinary, everyday English, make sure all of the relevant points of the discussion are clearly explained, and be sure to keep your discussion straightforward and to the point - remember, I don't want any commentary or criticism on this assignment, just summarize as accurately as you can the passages I've indicated.

Reference no: EM133484822

Questions Cloud

What should be place to protect them from unnecessary pain : If you agree to animal testing, what limits should be in place to protect them from unnecessary pain and suffering?

What is a description of the bystander effect : What is a discussion of how personal accountability in an emergency can be affected when around other passive bystanders.

What do you think about aristotles realism about money : What do you think about Aristotle's realism about money and health or his concept of moral luck - that you can be a good person but still suffer misfortune.

Pros and cons of issue in a well-organized sequence of ideas : A fair-minded, balanced, and objective development of the pros and cons of the issue in a well-organized sequence of ideas, free of mechanical errors

Discuss the wives of the guardians of his ideal city : In the first few pages of Book V of Plato's Republic, Socrates is discussing the role that women will play as "wives" of the guardians of his ideal city.

Discuss your impression of the meeting as it relates : Discuss your impression of the meeting as it relates to the collaboration between members of the IEP team, compliance with IDEA, and whether ethical principles

How can teachers and schools improve how they collaborate : How can teachers and schools improve how they collaborate with families in this way? How does a Christian worldview encourage compassion and care towards all

Discuss these challenges but do not just list the challenges : Discuss these challenges but do not just list the challenges noted in our textbook. Come up with some of your own ideas and tells us why you believe these

How can we make sure to support racial equity : How can we best support families and students while working with remote learning and teaching? How can we make sure to support racial equity and best practice

User Account

All Pages