Discuss the specific objections that marsha should raise

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131117739

Assignments & Exams Course:

Laws of Evidence: Assignment Felix returned from work and found his roommate Oscar shaking, vomiting, and moaning in pain. Felix quickly drove Oscar to a nearby emergency room. On the way to the hospital, Oscar said: "Marsha did this." At the emergency room, a doctor immediately took Oscar's medical history. Oscar told the doctor: "A friend gave me some brownies. They tasted a little funny, but I ate them. About ten minutes later, my heart started beating fast, this shaking started, and I had to vomit. Help me!"

A police officer, who had just transported another patient to the emergency room, overheard Oscar's statement. "Who gave you those brownies?" the officer demanded. "We have to make sure he doesn't give them to anyone else. This could be a bioterrorist attack!" Oscar told the police officer, "It was my friend Marsha, but I'm sure she's not a terrorist. She's just a bad cook." Oscar then lapsed into a coma; the following day he died of heart failure. An autopsy revealed that Oscar had been poisoned with dried venom taken from a Colorado River Toad (Bufo Alvarius). That toad's venom causes hallucinations, nervous seizures, vomiting, and heart failure. After a full police investigation, the prosecutor charged Marsha with first-degree murder.

The prosecutor claims that Marsha intentionally poisoned Oscar with venom-laden brownies. At trial, the prosecutor plans to introduce the following evidence: Felix's testimony that, on the way to the hospital, Oscar said "Marsha did this." Oscar's patient chart from the hospital, in which the doctor recorded Oscar's statement that: "A friend gave me some brownies. They tasted a little funny, but I ate them. About ten minutes later, my heart started beating fast, this shaking started, and I had to vomit. Help me!"

The emergency room's head nurse will testify that the hospital has regular guidelines for documenting patient illnesses, and that Oscar's chart complied with those guidelines. The head nurse did not hear Oscar's statement; the doctor who treated him is not available to testify at trial.

The police officer's testimony that Oscar said "my friend Marsha" when asked who gave him the brownies. Testimony by Dr. Todd Croak, an expert on animal toxins, that: "In my opinion, the venom of a Colorado River Toad is so poisonous that any food containing this toad's venom was intended to kill the recipient." Marsha's attorney has stipulated that the field of animal toxins is an appropriate one for expert testimony and that Croak is qualified in that field.

Testimony from Marsha's sister, Patty, that Marsha has a longstanding habit-dating back to childhood-of collecting and torturing toads.

Apart from the stipulation noted in part (d) above, Marsha's attorney plans to challenge each of these pieces of evidence.

Please discuss the specific objections that Marsha should raise with respect to each piece of evidence and the likelihood of prevailing on those objections.

Reference no: EM131117739

Questions Cloud

Determine whether such a strategy would have been profitable : Assume that the euro’s spot rate has moved in cycles over time. How might you try to use futures contracts on euros to capitalize on this tendency? How could you determine whether such a strategy would have been profitable in previous periods?
Involved in the different types of financial transactions : Discuss risks involved in the different types of financial transactions. You may focus your answer on any financial assets or transaction types.
Conduct an audit of the safety management system elements : Conduct an audit of the following safety management system elements at your organization, or an organization with which you are familiar and have access to the required information
Create a method that performs an animation appropriate : Then, create a way to start and stop the ride using the While something is true event
Discuss the specific objections that marsha should raise : Can An Individual In A Dating Relationship Be Charged With Domestic Violence Crimes If He Or She Hits His Or Her Partner?
The financial statements of campbell soup company : a. As of July 28, Year 11, Campbell owned 33% of Arnotts Limited. Explain where Campbell reports the amounts representing this investment.
Determining the restrictive covenant : Restrictive covenant - financial institutions usually restrict the firms so as to safeguard their funds. They do this by way of restrictive covenants which include asset based covenant, cash flow, liability etc.
A producer of security systems : Amexicorp, Inc., a producer of security systems, had sales of $400 million, cost of goods sold of $150 million, operating expenses of $100 million, and interest expense of $100 million.
Explain why an mnc may use forward contracts to hedge : Why might Forward contracts be advantageous for committed transactions, and currency options be advantageous for anticipated transactions?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Organization recruiting challenges and solutions

What kinds of recruiting challenges do organizations face?

  Explore the artistic conventions for egyptian representation

Discuss the artistic conventions for Egyptian representation seen on the Egyptian high rank statues.

  Compare their experiences and lessons learned can any of

need essay 4-5 typed pages double spaced on following jane austens use of irony in her novels offers important insights

  Appropriate uses for various communication channels

In this presentation assignment, you will visually explain the appropriate uses for various communication channels in online courses.

  Brief summary of your understanding of malingering

Brief summary of your understanding of malingering, and why you think criminal defendants might be inclined to malinger. Discuss the benefits and limitations of tools forensic psychology professionals use to determine if a criminal defendant is ma..

  Alcohols ethanol-butanol and isopropanol are best described

The alcohols ethanol, butanol, and isopropanol are best described how?

  Pseudo-equilibrium hypothesis-pseudo-steady-state assumption

Use both the “pseudo-equilibrium hypothesis” and the “pseudo-steady-state assumption” to derive a rate expression.  Do both rate expressions agree with the experimental?

  Change the hypothesis to a ho

Change the hypothesis to a Ho

  Concept of competitive advantage

The concept of competitive advantage is as important for not-for-profit organizations as it is for for-profit organizations.” Do you agree or disagree with this statement? Explain, using examples to make your case

  Identify the three stages in the model of interviewing

Identify the three stages in the model of interviewing. Detail elements of each stage that assist in supporting interviewing skills

  What are the divisions of the brain

What are the divisions of the brain that research psychologists are most interested in? Describe what divisions of the brain one might be interested in researching?

  Possible violations of moral rights

In your judgment, were the possible utilitarian benefits of building the Caltex plant in 1977 more important than the possible violations of moral rights and of justice that may be involved?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd