User Account

All Pages

Discuss the moral reasoning involved in addressing

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM132218439

Question: This week, we will consider how utilitarianism applies to a certain situation that happened in Malaysia.

Please watch this video on utilitarianism and the ethical question we will consider: UtilitarianismLinks to an external site.

This is a real world example of a moral problem that can be answered one way using utilitarian ethical decision making or in other ways using other ethical theories (which we will discuss in the coming weeks).

The ethical controversy surrounds the building of a dam that will provide hydro-electric power for millions of people in the metropolitan areas of Malaysia. In order to build this dam 10,000 people, who live in the jungle where the dams will be built, will need to be relocated. Then, the lands where their ancestors have lived for hundreds of years will be flooded, in order to create an enormous lake that will supply the hydro-power for the generation of electricity.

The ethical question is whether the increase in pleasure that will be provided to millions of people in the metropolitan areas by having cheaper and more reliable electricity, outweighs the pain that would be caused to the 10,000 indigenous people who will be forced to relocate to another part of the country and will have to leave their ancestral lands. In addition, there will be a large amount of environmental damage caused to the area that is flooded, by the destruction of the land, the building of the dam and the necessary mechanical components needed to get the electricity to the metropolitan areas.

If there are other issues that are relevant to making a moral decision on this topic, that I have not outlined, please feel free to mention them. For example, should we consider all of the animals that may die or be pushed out by the building of the dam, or do only people matter in this ethical decision?

This symposium is a chance for you to discuss together the ethical issues and questions that the video raises, your own response to those issues, and whether your opinion on the subject aligns with or does not align with a utilitarian approach. The aim is not to simply assert your own view or to denigrate other views, but to identify, evaluate, and discuss the moral reasoning involved in addressing whether or not the building of the dam, which will supply low cost electricity for millions of people, is ethically justified when considering the people who will have to lose their home and ancestral lands to build the dam, as well as the environmental damage that will be caused.

Reference no: EM132218439

Questions Cloud

Disadvantages of constructing versus purchasing assets : Imagine you are the senior accountant in the fixed assets department of your organization. Management is assessing the benefits of self-constructing.
Describe experiences with mass media : Describe one or two (1-2) experiences with mass media (movies or television) that affected you positively or negatively, explaining when, how, and why.
What would a utilitarian say is the right action : What would a utilitarian say is the right action in each of the cases? Give the reasoning by referring to Chapter 3 of the textbook, especially John Stuart.
Describe data flows in your company : Identify where you will use data collected from the Web and other sources of information such as sell statistics, user activity or social media data.
Discuss the moral reasoning involved in addressing : This symposium is a chance for you to discuss together the ethical issues and questions that the video raises, your own response to those issues.
Discuss some of the approaches to cybercrime : Discuss some of the approaches to cybercrime that are taken by both the Hong Kong and Singapore governments.
Define important characteristic of communities and biomes : Biodiversity is an important characteristic of communities and biomes. Efforts to preserve biodiversity, though intended to reduce human influence.
What are some of the groups that need accounting information : What are some of the groups that need accounting information? What kind of accounting information do they need? Why? Think of a company you've done business.
Summarize the article in two paragraphs : For your discussion post, your first step is to summarize the article in two paragraphs describing what you think are the most important points made.

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Consequences of rapidly increasing medical mal practice rate

President Bush stated in the State of the Union address that frivolous law suits were a priority for him this next year. No where is this more critical than in medical mal practice law suits. Reportedly, this past year, prior to the election, the Pre..

  What two metropolitan areas have the largest populations

What two metropolitan areas have the largest populations in the U.S. part of the North Pacific Coast Region

  Provide an example of a job that could have a high

provide an example of a job that could have a high incidence of workplace musculoskeletal disorders wmsds. identify

  Explain experience to alienate from work environment

Have you ever something like this when you worked the job you dislike, had to do task you seriously dislike and/ or were alienated from work environment?

  Granted antitrust immunity

Airline alliances could either benefit or hurt passengers. How should the US Department of Transportation and its counterparts in the European Union and elsewhere determine whether a proposed airline alliance should be granted antitrust immunity?

  Show how freedom of religion is protected

The author provides us with good cases that show how freedom of religion is protected. "I think it is not hard to see the wisdom in that decision.

  Discuss disproportionate minority confinement

What additional factors affect disproportionate minority confinement and minority youth

  What challenges might be unique to readers

What challenges do you think are unique to writers? What challenges might be unique to readers?

  Criminal trial-principles for juries and jury trials

What if they ask improper questions such as "How many times has the defendant been arrested before and for what?" Give reasons in support of your argument. Review the American Bar Association's (ABA's) (2005) "Principles for Juries and Jury Trials" a..

  How does crane explain changes in mans role in the modern

how does crane explain changes in mans role in the modern

  Question 1in many developing and least developed countries

question 1in many developing and least developed countries tourism is one of the principal and in some countries the

  Describe how various media are regulated differently

Describe how various media are regulated differently. What have been the justifications for this varying treatment

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

Submit Assignment

Academics

Major Subjects

Majors

Get In Touch

whatsapp: +1-415-670-9521

Phone: +1-415-670-9521

Email: [email protected]

TERMS & POLICIES

HELP & SUPPORT

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd