Discuss the compatibility of the biomedical discourse

Reference no: EM133517501

Assignment: Mental illness and mental health recovery- Critical Review

Length: 2500 words.

Overview

This assignment invites you to consider the underlying assumptions of the dominant model of mental illness and compare these with the principles of the recovery paradigm. It encourages you to think critically how these contrasting perspectives influence the assessment and treatment of mental health problems. In contemporary mental health care, clinical or case formulation continues to be exceptionally important and the capacity to make sense of a person's problems, rather than simply labelling or naming them, is an essential capability of all mental health professionals.

It is your opportunity to consider competing discourses which shape the need for other ways of being with people and assisting them than the dominant biomedical approach to mental health. You will do so by considering how a mental illness may be diagnosed and treated from a biomedical model. You are invited to consider the implications of formulating the from a psychotherapeutic framework. You will then consider the roles, virtues and competencies required to help the person from a position of biomedical discourse and the alternative framework.

Learning outcomes

This assessment task is aligned with the following learning outcomes:

I. Analyse and critique the dominant discourses and models of mental health and illness and how these and other formative influences have shaped mental health policy, legislation, professional standards, influenced mental health practice and the experience of care

II. Critically review the concept of the therapeutic alliance or relationship, its essential elements, how it can be developed and maintained, and argue its importance in contributing to collaboratively negotiated outcomes with service users.

III. Construct a clinical / case formulation drawing on psychotherapeutic theory, extant research and clinical reasoning which effectively addresses the holistic needs of the individual and families

Task

Is mental health recovery compatible with biomedical understandings of mental illness? Implications for the mental health workforce.

In essay format, your assignment should address the following:

Question A. Identify a single mental disorder as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistic Manual of Mental Disorders (5 th Edition, Text Review) (DSM-5-TR) (American Psychiatric Association, 2022)1 and briefly describe the dominant biomedical discourse around the disorder and how this discourse informs expectations about assessment, aetiology, treatment and clinical recovery of that disorder.

Question B. Identify a person you have worked with, or a case study from the literature, with the same DSM-5- TR diagnosis as identified in Part 1. Drawing on alternative discourses around personal recovery and/or psychotherapeutic literature2 , describe an alternative way of formulating the problem. Briefly describe the implications for the process of care and treatment from this perspective.

Question C. Discuss the compatibility of the biomedical discourse with the alternative discourses around the problem.

Question D. Compare and contrast the skills, competencies and attitudes needed by mental health workers to effectively respond to a person with this diagnosis from these discourses.

Reference no: EM133517501

Questions Cloud

What are the interview techniques most used by social worker : What are the interview techniques most used by social workers and in your opinion which ones do you think are the most effective?

States regulate the licensing requirements of health care : states regulate the licensing requirements of health care practitioners. Supposing this duty were handled at the federal level in an effort to save money

What administrative impact do hospital administrators have : What administrative impact do hospital administrators have in the area of patient billing in the decision-making process?

What is your opinion of the rorschach : What is your opinion of the Rorschach? Positive and / or negative based on what you have learned about it through research.

Discuss the compatibility of the biomedical discourse : Discuss the compatibility of the biomedical discourse with the alternative discourses around the problem.

Explain what are some health care third-party audits : which you will need to be knowledgeable? what is random self-audits? Do you think they can be helpful to you and your department if you were to obtain this

What you know about the medicare physician fee schedule : what you know about the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) and how it differs regarding participating providers versus non-participating providers

How would the christian worldview inform his view about : How would George interpret his suffering in light of the Christian narrative, with an emphasis on the fallenness of the world? How would George interpret his

Identify topic related to consciousness that interests you : Identify one topic related to consciousness that interests you. Additionally, consider what aspect of this topic you want to learn more about.

User Account

All Pages