Discuss singer principle of equal consideration of interests

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133226942

Assignment:

I am writing an essay based upon:

On New Year's Day, space aliens arrive on earth. After observing our treatment of cattle and fowl, they proceed to round up the human population and keep us in massive pens. Some humans they use for unspeakable medical experiments; others the aliens eat for lunch. When we object, claiming that we have a right to life and strong moral standing, the aliens - who are far more intelligent than we are - point to our treatment of animals and insist they are behaving exactly as we do: by making use of an inferior species.

Are the aliens right in their treatment of us? Or are they wrong? If they are wrong, does this imply that our treatment of animals is also wrong? What property or set of properties does an entity need before it has strong moral standing?

First, explain how Kant would answer these questions, making sure to detail why he would reply as you say he would.

Next, discuss Singer's principle of the equal consideration of interests and his argument from marginal cases, and talk about how Singer would respond.

Finally, discuss how Steinbock would reply and explain her reasoning.

Who makes the best case in the end? Why? Elaborate at length.

Reference no: EM133226942

Questions Cloud

What are the costs associated with burial versus cremation : What are the costs associated with burial versus cremation in your area? Where do you want to be buried or have your ashes deposited?

How is knowledge privileged in modern education : How is textbook knowledge privileged in modern education? What is the logic and motivation behind it?

Compare the theories of utilitarianism and kantian ethics : Using the criteria of adequacy for moral arguments, compare and contrast the theories of Utilitarianism and Kantian ethics.

What intentions count as ethical : Is it intentions or results which may be called moral or immoral? What intentions count as ethical? Is it based on reason or a "natural" feeling or sentiment?

Discuss singer principle of equal consideration of interests : Next, discuss Singer's principle of the equal consideration of interests and his argument from marginal cases, and talk about how Singer would respond.

Issues and concerns regarding its implementation : The NDIS promised to transform Australian lives for the better. But there are still some issues and concerns regarding its implementation. The complaints about

Explain evolutionary theory : According to evolutionary theory, behaviors that optimize survival and reproduction are favored by natural selection and, therefore, more likely to persist. How

Why cognitive processes can produce prejudice : Discuss how and why cognitive processes can produce prejudice. Once stereotypes and prejudices are formed, how do they come to be self-perpetuating?

Principles of behaviour change programs : Briefly explain how learning theories inform the principles of behaviour change programs

User Account

All Pages