Discuss policy reasons for this general practice

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM133411307

The APA allows private parties to petition federal agencies to commence rule-making proceedings on subjects within the agencies' jurisdiction. If the agency in question chooses to refrain from acting, it should promptly inform the petitioner or petitioners of its decision. The general practice, however, is that judicial review will not be available to the disappointed petitioners. The courts typically will review neither the agency's refusal to hold a hearing on the subject or its refusal to issue the requested rule. Please answer the three questions below as to this state of affairs:

1. Discuss policy reasons for this general practice, which exempts from judicial review an agency's refusal to act on the petition to commence rule-making. (Why might this general practice be good for public policy?)

2. Explain whether and why you agree or disagree with this general practice of declining to review an agency's refusal to act on a petition to commence rule-making.

3. Lay out one exception that you would propose to this usual rule. That is, if you were a judge, under what circumstances would you be persuaded than an agency must develop a rule? Your answer should be in clear English, not legalese.

Reference no: EM133411307

Questions Cloud

Draft the firm joint retainer letter agreement : Draft the Firm's Joint Retainer Letter Agreement for the matter, to be sent by Mr. Styles and addressed to both Jon and Mary for their signature.
Component of the learning process : The Learning Journal is an important component of the learning process for this course. Think of your learning journal as a diary
Procedures to safeguard sensitive information : Pendant Publishing has not yet updated its policies and procedures to safeguard sensitive information for both its employees and the organization
Marketing innovations and technology : Assess the role of legal and non-legal responses in recognising the rights of consumers. In your response refer to marketing innovations and technology.
Discuss policy reasons for this general practice : Discuss policy reasons for this general practice, which exempts from judicial review an agency's refusal to act on the petition to commence rule-making.
About international business and international law : What were 3 things you learned about international business and international law that you found useful during negotiations?
Analyze market structure of organic baby food industry : Analyze the market structure of the organic baby food industry in Canada.
Group development and team performance : Conflict is an important step in group development and team performance.
Define elements of actus reus and mens rea : Identify and define elements of actus reus and mens rea of the relevant non- fatal offences that may apply in the case studies.

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Requirement of the statute of frauds under the ucc

What is required to meet the writing requirement of the statute of frauds under the  UCC

  Why was the signing of the magna carta legally significant

Define the following words: autonomy, ratified, arbitrary, codify. Explain the importance of each of the four key principles from the Magna Carta.

  Brief summary of the facts

Find a news article or case in which the directors and/or officers of a corporation were accused of breaching their duties of care or loyalty. Provide a brief summary of the facts and discuss the standards that were used in determining that a brea..

  Explain susans duties to the principle

she wants to buy and sell the land to ABC Corp herself. Can she do this? Discuss this scenario and explain Susan's duties to the principle.

  Discuss contingency plans

Provide a concise "action plan" to implement your program that articulates priorities, timelines, and accountability. Be sure to discuss contingency plan.

  Examine the federal tort claims acts

Examine the Federal Tort Claims Acts (FTCA). Discuss whether these laws reduce the risk to citizens or does it serve a compelling state interest

  It turns out that steve has issues with the color fuchsia

larry hires steve to manage his apartment building. larry performs a thorough background check which shows no problems.

  What are berts rights against martin

At the time, in Bert's presence, Sharpie filled in the date on the note as February 2, 2010. Bert demanded payment from Martin, who refused to pay. What are Bert's rights against Martin?

  At the end of the year a local car dealer approaches

You are a manager of nonprofit orphanage. At the end of the year a local car dealer approaches you with a proposition.

  Identify the philosophical basis for each theory

Write a 1,050- to 1,750-word paper in which you evaluate your selected criminological theory. Identify the philosophical basis for each theory

  Case study of sara williams

Based on the Issue identified, provide an argument for McCarthy using specific facts of the case and the relevant legal theory to support it.

  How should the court rule on wade pretrial motions

How should the court rule on Wade's pretrial motions to exclude his statement to Officer Luthor at the scene of the arrest, the identification of Wade by Mettler at the police station, as well as the purse seized from Wade's car

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd