Reference no: EM133337121
Max Plc produces a range of especially designed tyres for domestic, commercial and
industrial use. Due to the different markets that they operate in they have divisionalised
into three autonomous departments, Domestic, Commercial and Industrial. They have
just reported their results for the year ended 30th September 2022, which are shown
below. (All figures in £'000)
Division
|
Domestic |
Commercial |
Industrial |
Total |
Sales
|
2,300 |
1,800 |
1,400 |
5,500 |
Operating Profit
|
700 |
400 |
300 |
1,400 |
Capital Employed
|
3,000 |
1,400 |
2,000 |
6,400 |
The company rewards divisional mangers based on the Return on Capital Employed and has a Cost of Capital of 14%. You may assume that the company does not pay corporation tax.
Required:
a) For each division and a company calculate
i. The Return on Capital Employed
ii. The Operating Profit Margin
iii. The Asset Turnover Rate
b) Utilising the calculations in (a) comment on the profitability of each of the divisions and identify potential reasons why their results may differ.
c) It has been put forward that the domestic division should expand its product range. New Investment would cost £600,000 and generate an additional £90,000 in profit. As the manager of the Domestic Division would you recommend that this opportunity be invested in.
d) Utilising the calculations in part (c) critically appraise the use of Return on Capital Employed as a measure of Divisional Manager performance.
e) Using the Company's Cost of Capital of 14%, calculate the Residual Income of each division, overall company and for the additional investment described in part (c).
f) Utilising your calculations in part (e) explain why Residual Income may be a superior measure of a Divisional Manager performance.
g) Discuss other non-financial performance measures you feel the company should adopt and justify your choice.