Discuss likely success of ian satisfying first two elements

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133478156

Problem

Johnny regularly engages Ian to clean his pool. One day Ian parks his van in the driveway in front of Johnny's double garage, which as usual is closed and locked while Johnny is at work. While Ian is cleaning the pool at the back of the house, a sudden hailstorm causes damage to Ian's van. Ian insists that Johnny compensate him for the damage to the van, since it occurred while Ian was on Johnny's property, and would not have happened if Johnny had left the garage door open for him. Should Johnny be compelled to compensate Ian?

Discuss the likely success of Ian satisfying the first two elements of a negligence claim: duty of care and breach of duty.

Below is a suggested structure for your response:

If Ian wishes to sue Johnny in negligence, then Ian would have to establish all essential elements of a negligence claim. In this case, we are asked to focus on the first two elements: duty of care and breach of duty.

Issue: The first element of negligence is duty of care. Therefore, the first issue to determine is whether Johnny owes Ian a duty of care?

Law:
Application:
Conclusion:

Issue: The second element of negligence is breach of duty. Therefore, the second issue to consider is whether Johnny has breached his duty of care?

Law:
Application:
Conclusion:

Reference no: EM133478156

Questions Cloud

What are the arguments lesters and peters should make : What are the arguments Lester's and Peter's should make in defense of not performing under their respective contracts?

Advise antonella of her legal rights and the likely outcome : Antonella was a street performer who had detailed ideas for a TV series based on her experiences. Advise Antonella of her legal rights and the likely outcome.

How will this help you in your career and personal life : How will this help you in your career and personal life? How would implementing this advice affect your personal and professional integrity?

List and define three components of the balance sheet : List and define three components of the balance sheet. - Describe the differences between financial and managerial accounting.

Discuss likely success of ian satisfying first two elements : Discuss the likely success of Ian satisfying the first two elements of a negligence claim: duty of care and breach of duty.

How does the legal rule apply to the set of facts in case : What is the legal question at the center of the case? How does the legal rule apply to the set of facts in the case? What was the final decision of the court?

Government weakest and strongest cybersecurity domain : What do you believe is the U.S. federal government's weakest and strongest cybersecurity domain/sector/program or concept?

What are factors that may influence what a person decides : What are factors that may influence what a person decides to research in the social sciences? What are factors that might influence what you will propose?

Was there a contract formed : When Polk refused to per her duties under the signed counteroffers, Avon filed a suit seeking specific performance. Was there a contract formed?

User Account

All Pages