paragraphs, and / or paragraphs, and has paragraphs, and has little or no headings headings clear headings a ... Submission is very WORD LENGTH The specified word The specified word The specified word length for each length for each length For each section /3 section is more than section is less than is less that 10% higher 20% higher or lower 20% higher or lower or lower ....- --- REFERENCES No APA style in-text Limited AM style in- Excellent AM style In- /3 reference list reference list citations used text citationsused text citatlOrts used throughout throughout throughout document document. No document Limited Full reference list

CONCLUSION No or wrong Correct conclusion Correct conclusion that /3 conclusion but which does not Is well-reasoned and arguments or with the arguments law tie-in with the above supported by the above /-31 ORGANISATION Submission lacks Submission Is clear organisation somewhat organised organised with well and / or undefined with reasonable constructed

Score : 0 to S Score : 6 to 10 Score :11-14 APPLICATION / EVALUATION / No / minimal or Some arguments / Good critical arguments /14 ACHIEVING OBJECTIVES (for reports): wrong arguments / reference and and application of the There must be application of the law evaluation. No / application or law to the facts of the to the facts of the question with minimal or wrong evaluation of the law question. Good critical supporting arguments to justify the pertinent facts. For but insufficient and For Reports / Memo - conclusion. For critical essay type Reports / Memo - not critical For All of the stated questions, students must Stated objectives not Reports / Memo • objectives achieved analyse and evaluate the law and objectives achieved reference to to the facts or issue evaluation and reforms.

Score : 0 to 2 Score : 3 to 5 score : 6-8 RELEVANT LAW / PROCEDURES: This No mention of Some mention of Correct and complete indudes relevant case-laws and authorities, wrong authorities but mention of relevant / statutes. and / or Irrelevant without showing authorities with legal principles or contrasting suffident elaboration of procedures without authorities and the legal principles and elaboration insufficient procedures elaboration or Inadequate procedures

no US case, only AUS/UK cases MInimum 10 references of cases + book on APA Score : 0 Score : 1 Score : 2 INTRODUCTION: Students to provide No introduction or An introduction that Complete and provides overview of the particular area and a succcint relevant the gereral requirements with superficial and / or introduction that fully governing legal principles. incomplete. addresses the question not relevant is relevant but Score : (Ito 1 Score : 2 to 3 Score :4 ISSUES: Students are to identify and Issues / sub-Issues Could identify the Identified all the Issues explain the main legal Issue as well as wrongly identified main issues but not / subAssues with the sub-issue(s). or incomplete and / the sub-issues and no sufficient elaboration elaboration or minimal in-depth elaboration