Discuss a company as an investment banking client

Assignment Help Accounting Basics
Reference no: EM131799027

1. Analysts are predicting that Krispy Kreme will be able to perform highly effectively and continue to grow rapidly in the coming two years.  Do you agree with their analysis?  If so, why?  If not, why not?

I was able to identify five key factors underlying growth as shown below.

  • Brand based on high quality product.
  • Fragmented regional competition with less brand recognition.
  • Strong opportunities to extend network of stores geographically.
  • Area developer model seems to be working. Company store data suggests that model probably works for area developers.

Revenues ($70 per week * 52)

$3,640

Gross profit at company rate (18%)

655

Royalties (5.5%)

-200

Mark up on KKM&D (8.2*royalties*17%)

-280

Capital charge (10%*$1.4m cost of a store)

-140

   

Net

35

Further, if area developer models go broke, Krispy Kreme seems to be able to operate them profitably.

  • Small store growth with new technology and international growth hold promise, although untested. Beginning to compete with Starbucks. Will donuts appeal to non Unites States markets?

There are two potential concerns I thought of.  First being the chance this is a fad and that consumers will get tired of donuts however they have been popular for many years.  Second is the threat of competition in the future.

2. What factors did the CIBC analysts examine to forecast sales growth for KKD in the years ended January 2003 and 2004?  What assumptions did they implicitly make about number of new stores and weekly sales per store (for both company and franchise stores)?  What are their implicit assumptions about revenue growth from franchise operations and KKM&D?  Do you agree with these forecasts?

The CIBC analysts' forecasts were constructed using per store information.  The company plans to add 62 new stores in 2003, mostly through area developers.  What are the revenues per new store?  Take into consideration the initial boom, followed by the leveling off.  Also, not all the new stores were open for an entire year.

Revenue growth per new store has been impressive.  Company store growth is stabilizing, dropping from 28% to 4% in last year.  Franchise store revenue growth is still high, as the number of area developers increase, with store revenue patterns comparable to company stores.  This is likely to persist for many years until revenues per store are similar for company and franchise stores.

Royalty revenues have been increasing over time since area developers pay higher royalty rates than old associates, 5.5% versus 3%.  These have averaged 4% for the last two years.  KKM&D revenues are driven by franchisee revenues, since sales are to franchisees and will vary with their volume.  They have averaged 33% of franchise sales in the last two years.

 

Feb. 3, 2002

Feb. 3, 2003

Feb. 3, 2004

Number of stores at end of period:

     

Company

75

80

87

Franchised

143

200

273

Total

218

280

360

       

Average # company stores

69

77.5

83.5

Average # franchise stores

127

171.5

236.5

       

Average weekly sales per store:

     

Company

$72

$75

$77

Franchised

53

60

65

       

Total Sales (average stores * weekly sales * 52)

     

Company sales

$258,336

$302,250

$332,163

Franchise sales

350,012

535,080

799,370

Total Sales

$608,348

$837,330

$1,131,533

       

Company Revenues:

     

Company stores

 

$302,250

$332,163

Franchise operations (4% of franchise sales)

 

21,403

31,975

KKM&D (32% of franchise sales)

 

171,226

255,798

Revenues

 

$494,879

$619,936

Revenue growth rate

 

25%

25%

3. What are the NOPAT margins that the CIBC analysts have forecasted for KKD for the years ended January 2003 and 2004?  What assumptions were made about specific expense items (e.g. margins, G&A, D&A, taxes)?  Do you agree with these forecasts?

  • Forecast Gross Profits per Store

These vary greatly by business.  For company stores they have increased to 18%.  Royalty income has a 65% margin and KKM&D is 17%.  The CIBC analysts have forecasted that margins increase to 19% for company stores, 70% for franchise operations, and 18-19% for KKM&D.  With that in mind, we get the following costs:

 

FEB. 3,

FEB. 3,

 

2003

2004

Gross Profit

   

Company stores (18%)

$54,405

$59,789

Franchise operations (65%)

13,912

20,784

KKM&D (17%)

29,108

43,486

 

$97,425

$124,059

  • Forecast Other Costs

G&A and Depreciation costs have averaged 9% of sales for the last three years.  The CIBC analysts show this 9% declining in 2004 to 8.74%.  In addition, minority interest has been around 0.3% of the franchise revenues for the last two years.

 

FEB. 3,

FEB. 3,

 

2003

2004

Other expenses (9% of sales)

$44,539

$55,794

Minority Interest (0.3% of franchise sales)

1,605

2,398

  • Forecast Interest Expense

This requires some assumptions to be made about the firm's capital structure.  The beginning capital structure is given, and shows that the company has negative debt of $20 million.  This arises from the prior year's decision to raise new equity to meet future growth plans.  As a result, if the interest rate on these short term cash resources is 3%, the company's interest income will be about $600,000.

This implies that it will probably draw down cash for the next year.  It seems reasonable to assume that the company expects to draw down its cash ($37 million in Feb. 2002) almost completely to finance its growth.  This would imply that net debt would be close to zero in a year's time, leaving no interest income or expense.

  • Forecast Tax Rate

The following is considering a rate which has been around 38%.

 

FEB. 3,

FEB. 3,

2003

2004

     

Company Revenues

   

Company stores

$302,250

$332,163

Franchise operations (4% of franchise sales)

21,403

31,975

KKM&D (32% of franchise sales)

171,226

255,798

Revenues

$494,879

$619,936

Gross Profit

   

Company stores (18%)

$54,405

$59,789

Franchise operations (65%)

13,912

20,784

KKM&D (17%)

29,108

43,486

 

97,425

124,059

Other expenses (9% of sales)

44,539

55,794

Minority Interest (0.3% of franchise sales)

1,605

2,398

Earnings before interest

51,281

65,867

Interest Income

600

0

Earnings before tax

51,881

65,867

Tax Expense (38%)

19,715

25,029

Net Income

$32,166

$40,837

This implies that the company's NOPAT margin is 6.4% in 2003 and 6.6% in 2004, versus 6.3% in 2002.  In contrast, the CIBC forecasts show a NOPAT margin of 7.4% and 8.1%.

4. The CIBC analysts do not forecast KKD's balance sheet for the following year (ended January 2003).  Make your own balance sheet forecasts.

  • Forecast operating assets

KKD has shown a large increase in working capital this year, mostly in the form of receivables for franchisees.  Given the projected 25% growth in sales, the working capital/sales rate increases from 2.3% to 4.3%.  For next year's balance sheet, I will assume this increase will likely continue.  Therefore, working capital will be as follows given the former sales growth rates:

 

FEB. 3,

FEB. 3,

2002

2003

     

Beginning net working capital (4% of sales)

21,142

24,805

Beginning long-term assets have increased as a percentage of sales from 20% to 25% in year 2001 and 2002.  For 2003, based on forecasted sales growth of 25% and actual long-term asset growth in 2002, the beginning long-term assets to sales ratio becomes 30%.  I will assume that this rate is stable at 20% and the long-term assets will be as follows:

 

FEB. 3,

FEB. 3,

2002

2003

     

Beginning long-term assets (30% of sales)

146,950

186,038

  • Forecast Capital Structure

I have assumed that KKD's negative net debt position will be eliminated by the beginning of 2004, as the company uses its excess cash to finance growth.  This implies that the company will be an all equity firm.  This is not likely to continue since the company will probably have positive net leverage over the long term.

The condensed balance sheet will be as follows:

 

FEB. 3,

FEB. 3,

2002

2003

Operating Assets

   

Beginning net working capital

21,142

24,805

Beginning long-term assets

146,950

186,038

 

168,092

210,843

     

Net Capital

   

Net debt

-19,575

0

Common equity

187,667

210,843

 

168,092

210,843

5. In general, do you expect analysts' forecasts for a company like KKD to be optimistic, pessimistic or unbiased?  Why?

Most of the incentives faced by financial analysts are likely to lead to optimistic research.  There are two factors I could think of affecting analyst incentives. 

First is investment banking opportunities.  Analysts receive significant bonuses if they play a role in attracting a company as an investment banking client, or if they participate in selling a new issue to investors.  This makes it unlikely that analysts will be very critical of a company, since they want to encourage its management to use the firm for any new equity placements.

Second are brokerage services.  Analysts at many banks are rewarded based on commissions generated for the companies they follow.  This creates incentives to producing research that encourages investors to trade.  Given the costs of short selling and the identifying investors that already own a stock, it is easier for analysts to increase trading volume by producing research that encourages investors to purchase a stock.  This incentive is very strong for analysts that cater to retail investors.  Institutional investors also reward using commissions, but they are more explicit about providing feedback on which particular reports were valuable.  They also have access to research reports from other analysts, making it easier to rate an analysts research relative to other analysts covering the same company.

Reference no: EM131799027

Questions Cloud

Household delinquency in payment : At the 5% significance level, test whether the type of heating influences a household's delinquency in payment. Interpret your results.
What is alignment in the context of the information systems : What is alignment in the context of the information Systems Strategy Triangle and why is it important for a business to be in alignment?
Why would chrysler have instituted the production change : Why would Chrysler have instituted this production change for its most popular (and profitable) vehicles, its minivans and Jeep Cherokee?
Identify organisation which would benefit from application : identify an organisation which would benefit from the application of these ideas and explain how the ideas should be applied
Discuss a company as an investment banking client : Analysts receive significant bonuses if they play a role in attracting a company as an investment banking client
Prepare classified balance sheet and notes if necessary : Equipment had a cost of $132,000 and accumulated depreciation of $28,000. Prepare classified balance sheet (to be audited) and notes (if necessary)
Text website labeled arlington homes : Access the data file on the text website labeled Arlington Homes. It contains data on various variables, including price and square footage
Expalin the directive autocrat and the permissive autocrat : Although any attempt to divide human beings into discrete categories can't be perfect, these patterns do seem to make good sense.
Determining the importance of religion : In order to test this claim, assume 400 randomly selected Massachusetts residents are asked about the importance of religion in his/her life.

Reviews

Write a Review

Accounting Basics Questions & Answers

  Entity separate and distinct from its owners

lhe corporation Is an entity separate and distinct from Its owners. lhe llablllty of stockholders Is nonnally llmlted to their Investment In the corporation.

  Ferguson company purchased a depreciable asset for 100000

ferguson company purchased a depreciable asset for 100000. the estimated salvage value is 10000 and the estimated

  Show the effects of the above transactions in a horizontal

the following transactions apply to baker co. for 2010 its first year of operations. 1.issued 160000 of common

  For each item state whether it should be classifed as a

1. for each item state whether it should be classifed as a current liability on the december 31 2011 balance sheet.

  According to peter fotios one of kerry group top requirement

According to Peter Fotios, one of Kerry Group top requirements was ease of integration with its existing SAP system. Why might a company select a sourcing system that was not as easy to integrate with its existing SCM software?

  The company has an offer from duvall valves to produce the

howell corporation produces an executive jet for which it currently manufactures a fuel valve the cost of the valve is

  Who is covered by the walsh healey public contracts

Who is covered by the Walsh Healey Public Contracts Act?

  Jj motors inc employs 45 sales personnel to market their

jj motors inc. employs 45 sales personnel to market their line of luxury automobiles. the average car sells for 23000

  Operating lease for tax purposes

Was the lease a capital lease (conditional purchase in tax terms) or a true operating lease for tax purposes?  As noted above, justify your answer.

  Discuss how cadburys accounting for the unexpected losses

Discuss how Cadbury's accounting for the unexpected losses would affect comparisons to a U.S. GAAP company with a similar unexpected gain.

  Methods for evaluating investments in research-development

"It is impossible to use DCF methods for evaluating investments in research and development. There are no cost savings to measure, and we don't even know what products might come out of our R&D activities."

  Traditional components of the triple constraint

Which of the following is not one of the PMBOK®?Guide's five process groups?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd