Difference between mercy killing and premeditated murder

Reference no: EM13329595

t the first trial Justice Noble attempted to clarify the difference between mercy killing and premeditated murder, granting Latimer a constitutional exemption from the minimum sentence of 25 years with no chance of parole for 10 years. He explained that, for Latimer, imposing the minimum sentence would constitute cruel and unusual punishment. The law, he said, recognizes that the moral culpability or the moral blameworthiness of murder can vary from one convicted offender to another. In his opinion, the murder pf Tray Latimer was a rare act of homicide that was committed for caring, altruistic reasons. That is why, for lack of a better term, this is called compassionate homicide.

To what extent did the supreme Court uphold Justice Nobles judicial rationale? support your answer.

Was the trial judge justified in departing from mandatory sentencing provisions? Should the motive of compassion be taken into account in sentencing someone convicted of murder?

Reference no: EM13329595

Questions Cloud

How can they be remedied : Discuss one or two weaknesses of filipinos, especially in relation to nation-building. Why do you consider them weaknesses? How can they be remedied?

Problems related to creating preliminary-rom budgets : What might be some potential problems related to creating preliminary and ROM budgets? When preparing these types of budgets is it better to be conservative or liberal in your estimates?

Identify the three elements the supreme court recognized : Identify the three elements the Supreme Court recognized that must be present to order for necessity to succeed as a defense

Validity and reliability in assessments important : Why are validity and reliability in assessments important? Can you have one without the other?

Difference between mercy killing and premeditated murder : Was the trial judge justified in departing from mandatory sentencing provisions? Should the motive of compassion be taken into account in sentencing someone convicted of murder?

Where will be the greatest growth in job creation : Where will be the greatest growth in job creation? Do your own research and see if this has to come to pass

Defence of necessity in the criminal law incorporates : The defence of necessity in the criminal law incorporates the moral principle that every individual who is not morally culpable for the of offence should not be punished. Such a common law defence to a crime applies only under circumstances where the..

What is the cost of the bear put spread : Consider a long box spread using AZN by buying a bull call spread and buying a bear put spread. Answer the following questions. A) What is the cost of the bull call spread? B) What is the cost of the bear put spread?

What is a government budgetdeficit : What is a government budgetdeficit? How does a federal budget deficit affect the economy? Howdoes it affect the level of investment and interest rates? How doesit affect the individual consumer? Give at least three examples inyour response.

User Account

All Pages