Did ashley do something morally wrong here

Reference no: EM133314117

Case Study: Ashley has a good friend, who will sell her a car at a very low price. The price is low not just because they are friends, but really because the car was stolen last year. The friend wasn't the thief who stole the car, but the car has now become the friend's car and the car also has a new title (also illegally accomplished already). If Ashley agrees to buy the car, she gets the clean title and Ashley cannot be linked to the theft, too. Ashley does agree to buy the car from her friend.
Question: For the purposes of this Observation, assume that neither Ashley nor her friend will get in trouble for participating in this deal. They will never get caught. Focus on the ethical question, not the worry about the law. The ethical question is: Did Ashley do something morally wrong here? Could Ashley's purchase of the stolen car pass the Categorical Imperative test?
Put another way, would everyone doing what she did be something that could be part of the Kingdom of Ends?
If she did do something immoral, put into your own clear words exactly why her decision is immoral. Or, maybe you think Ashley isn't morally wrong here -- but give reasons why it is OK, despite what the other students against Ashley's decision would say.

Reference no: EM133314117

Questions Cloud

Explain and identify any additional clauses you believe : Explain and identify any additional clauses you believe should be inserted into a final contract - Consider, for example, but do not limit discussion

Explain and critically assess thomas pogges argument : Briefly explain and critically assess Thomas Pogge's argument that "we are violating the human rights of the world's poor".

Direction in demanding dynamic situation : Leadership in setting direction in demanding dynamic situation for the organization and uses effective and responsive communication to align people with

What does current research say about banks : What does current research say about banks as a source of funding for new ventures? It is less common than the life-cycle model suggests It is the same as the

Did ashley do something morally wrong here : Did Ashley do something morally wrong here? Could Ashley's purchase of the stolen car pass the Categorical Imperative test?

What the term deontological and utilitarian mean : explaining why you agree or disagree with what the questionnaire has labeled you. Be sure you've reviewed some of the material on Ethics especially if you're

What do we advise ngt on how to set that up : Over the semester NGT has thrived in no small part thanks to your good advice as associates of the firm. Given that goal, what do we advise NGT on how to set

Did either of the parties act unethically : Did either of the parties act unethically and Should the court issue an injunction - If not, why? If so, what should the penalty be

What can we deduce about who is buying certain products : What can we deduce about who is buying certain products and services? For example, which shows air advertisements for cleaning products, children's medicine

User Account

All Pages