Dias and bartleby-a christmas carol

Assignment Help HR Management
Reference no: EM132824819

Dias and Bartleby

A Christmas Carol

The workplace in Bartleby's or Scrooge's () time was quite different from today. It was more like today's professional environment. Lawyers today are expected to be fully knowledgeable and have a professional work ethic learned in law school. Professional schools (architecture, engineering, medicine, law, and--not enough--business) include that in their curricula. So new lawyers today are given the sort of leeway that Bartleby and the scriveners have to decide on how they will do their work. It was largely F.W. Taylor and his Scientific Management movement that took decision making away from rank-and-file workers. Managers started designing the job and telling workers exactly what to do.

Much of this conversation assumes the 20th Century model of managers dictating. How does it change our conversation to think of that work environment more like our professional one?

Is there a bigger issue at work than insubordination? By hiring Bartleby in the first place, does the Lawyer owe any duty to Bartleby? Or is employment-at-will ethically enough?

A student once asked, "maybe I'm not sympathetic enough?" I'm not suggesting they were or weren't. Rather, this is a good place (this class) to consider what duties companies have to the people they hire and the communities in which they operate. Our English common law tradition gives us employment-at-will. I can quit today, and you can fire me today. All that is owed is today's wages. The contract period is only today, unless the parties enter into a different, formal contract, such as partners in a law firm. (If you watched Mad Men you saw that top executives were given lucrative employment contracts, and the story lines played out the ramifications of those.)

But, does a firm have only that responsibility? Labor unions fought for and won practices like vacation time, health- and life-insurance, and other benefits. Certainly these were unheard of in Bartleby's time. They would have been thought stealing from the employer. If we consider we are on an arc of history, where have we come from in terms of employer duty to employee, and where might we be going?

Reference no: EM132824819

Questions Cloud

Pursues differentiation strategy : Identify two companies, one that you believe pursues a lowest-cost strategy and another that pursues a differentiation strategy.
Describe the objectives for the older adult : Review the Healthy People 2030 objectives for the older adult. Of the objectives listed for the older adult, which two do you feel are most important.
What is the book value per share of ordinary shares : Ordinary share, 20,000 shares, 40 par 800,000 and Accumulated profits 960,000. What is the book value per share of ordinary shares
Compute the finance charge on the credit card account : Use the average daily balance method to compute the finance charge on the credit card account for the month of August? (31 days)
Dias and bartleby-a christmas carol : The workplace in Bartleby's or Scrooge's () time was quite different from today. It was more like today's professional environment.
Does anyone else at school need to be involved in solution : Does anyone else at the school need to be involved in the solution? Where is the power leverage in the school to reach the preferred solution?
Journal entries using the area of interest method : Journal entries using the area of interest method for 2018, 2019, and 2020. Calculations should be rounded to the nearest dollar
Explain what is the impact on gamestop financial statements : We establish a liability upon the issuance of merchandise credits and the sale of gift cards, what is the impact on Gamestop's financial statements?
What are the seven steps to establishing an agreement : What are the seven steps to establishing an agreement in the chosen organization to conduct the planning process in a systematic way.

Reviews

Write a Review

HR Management Questions & Answers

  Improve problem solving capabilities within organization

Types of teams as to their effectiveness that will improve problem solving capabilities within organizations.

  Influence tactics help in reducing organizations politics

Explain the different types of influence tactics that will be of a help “if adopted” in reducing the organizational politics.

  Report on citigroup''s hr service level agreement

Human Resources or Human Resource Management deals with HR Service Level Agreement. HR Service Level Agreement is an agreement made between the employer and the employee, which states that the employee would work under any client and sometimes any ti..

  A project report on hrm

Human Resource Management as the name suggests, it is a management discipline which deals with the human i.e. the workforce aspect of organizations. Need and practices of HRM are inevitable in present scenario of extreme competition where "Talent War..

  Hrp: recruitment and selection

Recruitment and Selection is the initial ladder of any Human Resource Planning process and contains an immense significance for any organisation.

  A project report on study of statutory complainces

Statutory compliance and its immense knowledge are crucial to be understood in an organization. It contains all the forms, procedures and acts applicable in a company.

  Operant conditioning and Reinforcement

Operant conditioning is a learning process where behaviour is controlled by its consequences. In this process an individual's behaviour can be modified through the use of positive or negative reinforcement.

  Effectiveness of training programs in achieving customers an

The main motive for conducting this research is to provide broad range of research of the literature and their reviews related to training and development and assisting the employees in providing customers satisfaction.

  A critical analysis of hr processes and practices in fedex c

FedEx is illustrious for its novel HR processes and practices that have greatly accounted for its success.

  Integrating culture and diversity in decision making

People in the organization are known as Google where they share common goals and have common vision.

  Impact of employee attrition on people management in organis

Talent management implies recognizing a person's inherent skills, traits, personality and offering him a matching job.

  Labour dissonance at maruti suzuki india limited: a case stu

This Case Study focuses on various issues related to Labour Unrest at Maruti Suzuki India Limited.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd