Description of the case from amy howe at scotusblog

Assignment Help History
Reference no: EM133321755

Assignment:

The Supreme Court heard oral arguments this week on 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis. For this question, you should read the following description of the case from Amy Howe at Scotusblog and then discuss the following issues:

  1. How should this case be decided?
  2. Is Smith's statement protected speech? Is her graphic design work a form of art?
  3. May the state of Colorado compel an artist to produce speech with which they disagree?
  4. Has Colorado's law been narrowly tailored?

You are welcome to consult further outside sources if you wish, and you may also wish to cover issues that are not specifically raised in the list of questions above. But this is not required. >> Nearly four years after the Supreme Court declined to decide whether compelling a Colorado baker to bake a cake for same-sex couples would violate his right to freedom of speech, the justices agreed to take up a similar question in another case from Colorado, this time involving a website designer. The justices' decision to grant review in 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis sets up yet another major ruling on the intersection between LGBTQ rights and religious beliefs. The case that the court agreed on Tuesday to hear was filed by Lorie Smith, who owns a graphic design firm and wants to expand her business to include wedding websites. Because she opposes same-sex marriage on religious grounds, Smith does not want to design websites for same-sex weddings, and she wants to post a message on her own website to explain that.

But a Colorado law prohibits businesses that are open to the public from discriminating against gay people or announcing their intent to do so. Smith went to federal court, seeking a ruling that Colorado could not enforce its anti-discrimination law against her. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit agreed that Smith's "creation of wedding websites is pure speech," and that Colorado law compels Smith to create speech that she would otherwise refuse. But the anti-discrimination law does not violate the Constitution in this case, the court of appeals concluded, because the law is narrowly tailored to the state's interest in ensuring that LGBTQ customers have access to the unique services that Smith provides.

Same-sex couples might be able to have their wedding websites designed by someone else, the court of appeals explained, but those customers "will never be able to obtain wedding-related services of the same quality and nature as those that" Smith offers. After considering the case at four consecutive conferences, the justices agreed to take up Smith's claim under the free speech clause of the First Amendment.

They declined to review two other questions that Smith raised in her petition for review: whether requiring Smith to create custom websites for same-sex couples violates the First Amendment's free exercise clause, and whether the Supreme Court should overrule its 1990 decision in Employment Division v. Smith, which held that government actions usually do not violate the free exercise clause as long as they are neutral and apply to everyone. The case nonetheless promises to be a major ruling because it may clarify when business owners who are engaged in expressive activities are entitled to religious-based exemptions from laws protecting civil rights.

Reference no: EM133321755

Questions Cloud

Concept of new political governance : The concept of New Political Governance; from the paper called: New Political Governance in Westminster Systems: Impartial Public Administration.
How much do you think social media influences elections : How much do you think social media influences elections? Why? Why do you think so few young people come out to vote?
Summarize healthcare policy that was adopted : The Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act, In a few paragraphs, summarize at least one healthcare policy that was adopted.
Discuss the argument regarding universal cash benefits : Briefly discuss the argument regarding Universal Cash Benefits. What are some of the reasons given for and against this position.
Description of the case from amy howe at scotusblog : For this question, you should read the following description of the case from Amy Howe at Scotusblog. How should this case be decided?
Concept of positive freedom : Summarize Berlin's concept of "positive freedom". How does this view of freedom relate to different views of the self?
How did women participate in the french revolution : How did women participate in the French Revolution? What were their goals? Did they achieve them?
Would say public is generally knowledgeable about politics : What is the concern for democracy of widely believed conspiracy theories or high levels of misinformation?
What are weaknesses-shortcomings-blind spots of a concept : What are the main arguments proponents make about the concept? What are the weaknesses/shortcomings/blind spots of a concept?

Reviews

Write a Review

History Questions & Answers

  History of imperialism and colonialism

Discuss the specific connections between economic development and imperialism in the latter half of the 20th century.

  Explain immigration to america

Explain immigration to America during the half of 19 th century

  American society in the making

American Society in the Making

  Conditions of late 19th century worker

Some historians considered the industrialists of the late 19th Century to be captains of industry while others considered them robber barons. Which view do you believe to be correct and why.

  Explaining the transition of humankind

Explain the significance of the transition of humankind from a hunter-gatherer society to a food-producing society. Include the following: A description of the Paleolithic era

  Tombs and monuments

Tombs and Monuments: Compare an aspect of the tomb of Emperor Shihuangdi with the burial tombs of other cultures, such as Egypt or Mesopotamia. Explain whether you think the emperor's elaborate tomb was motivated by power or religious beliefs.

  Accomplishments of egyptian female

Can anyone educate me regarding one distinct Mesopatamian and one Egyptian female and their accomplishments?

  Describing the characteristics of mesopotamia

What are the characteristics of the first civilizations of 5000 years ago? Especially in Mesopotamia.

  Explaining the vulnerability of mesopotamia

Determine why Mesopotamia was so vulnerable.

  Difference between egypt and mesopotamia

Some have said that the strength and endurance of the Empire and the regular, dependable recurrence of the Nile flood gave the artists-craftsmen a sense of consistency that profoundly influenced the nature of their artistic creations.

  Characteristics of first civilizations

What are the characteristics of the first civilizations of 5000 years ago( especially in the Mesopotamia)? what makes these groups "civilized" as opposed to prehistoric peoples?

  Growth and change in society

Cultures of Mesopotamia, especially Summer, and Egypt. How cultures change over time.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd