Describe to the firmer and softer versions of the theory

Reference no: EM133279405

Question: Author T. Jewis (1996) tells the story of how linguistic relativity "works." He was interested in why the Zulu language has that amount of words for "green," whereas English has only one. So he asked a Zulu chief. The Zulu chief explained that prior to national highways the Zulu had to make long treks across the savannah grasslands. Because there were no signposts or maps, the lengthy journeys had to be described by those who had traveled the road before. The language changed to accommodate the need for "finely wrought, beautiful logical descriptions of nature, causation, repetition, duration, and results" (p. 16). Lewis describes the conversation:

"But give me some examples of different green-words," I persisted.

My friend picked up a leaf. "What color is this?" he asked.

"Green," I replied.

The sun was shining. He waited until a cloud intervened. "What color is the leaf now?" he asked.

"Green," I answered, already sensing my inadequacy.

"It isn't the same green, is it?"

"No, it isn't."

"We have a different word in Zulu." He dipped the leaf in water and held it out again. "Has the color changed?"

"Yes."

"In Zulu we have a word for 'green shining wet.'"

The sun came out again and I needed another word (leaf-green-wet-but-with-sunshine-on-it!).

My friend retreated 20 meters and showed me the leaf. "Has the color changed again?"

"Yes," I screamed.

"We have another word," he said with a smile.

He went on to indicate how different Zulu greens would deal with tree leaves, bush leaves, leaves vibrating in the wind, river greens, pool greens, tree trunk greens, crocodile greens--he got to 39 without even raising a sweat, (p. 160)

Summarizes the Sapir Whorf Hypothesis.

Describe to the firmer and softer versions of the theory.

Relate this story to what the text says about Variation in Vocabulary.

Reference no: EM133279405

Questions Cloud

Drawing on the australian community work practice : Drawing on the Australian Community Work Practice Guidelines, briefly explain in your own words the points of relevance to this case scenario, having regard

What research methods would they use : How would an anthropologist, or psychologist, or sociologist study Child Abuse ?What would they focus on Child Abuse and what research methods would they use?

Discuss three techniques discussed in class : SOC 318 American River College discuss three techniques discussed in class. what are the functions of such techniques? give examples to support.

Identify one way that the groups characteristics : Identify one way that the groups characteristics inform how you provide care and services to them. Base the answers on culturally diverse workplace

Describe to the firmer and softer versions of the theory : Summarizes the Sapir Whorf Hypothesis and Describe to the firmer and softer versions of the theory - Relate this story to what the text says about Variation

What evidence you cite from the film to support your stance : Would you consider The Big Parade critical of US involvement in WWI or supportive? What evidence can you cite from the film to support your stance

How would you address a case involving the latter situation : PSY 09305 Rowan University How might you increase a child's self-confidence about his/her/their schoolwork and How would you address a case involving

What was meant by the slave power conspiracy : What was meant by the "Slave Power Conspiracy"? Do the historical events discussed in the Module II lectures suggest it was a real concern? Why or why not

What does it mean to say economy is embedded in society : SOCI 440 University of British Columbia, Okanagan what does it mean to say the economy is "embedded" in society? Why are there efforts to "disembed" the economy

User Account

All Pages