Describe the utilitarian approach to ethical reasoning

Assignment Help Finance Basics
Reference no: EM132642161

Case Study

Mike Howard and Nick Iles were ACCAs who were contracted by a Perth based second tier accounting practice, Bright, Candle and Light Partnership to supply a range of accounting, auditing and consultancy services to farmers and businesses in the Great Southern Region of Western Australia. This was the partnership's first attempt to enter the market in this region.

The partnership supplied office space in Albany and funded all necessary infrastructure and administrative expenses, which included the employment of a full time receptionist and office assistant. In return, Mike and Nick were required to contribute 60% of their gross earnings to the practice for all contract work.

Nick had been in the contract business for some years, but only recently moved down to Albany to work. He was single and had a half interest in a Mount Barker winery which absorbed much of his spare time and personal cash surplus. He prefers to operate alone and rarely provided support for Mike, whose experience in accounting was relatively limited. Mike, who was born in Albany, was married with two small children. He had recently built a home in the town and as the sole provider, was burdened with a significant mortgage.

Mike was conscientious and eager to establish a good client base. He willingly supported Nick with his client operations when the latter was unavailable and had not pressed Nick for any compensation for work undertaken on his behalf. At the same time, Mike's personality and genuine interest in the local business community was attracting some goodwill. Mike was fair and open with his clients, clearly explaining the fees and charges associated with the services he provided and regularly negotiated terms and conditions that best suited the client's budget. He attempted to accommodate their needs by organizing service contracts ensuring a good quality job was provided at a reasonable cost. He also provided pro bono services to local non-profit organizations.

When assisting Nick, Mike found that his colleague regularly over charged for services and was extravagant when determining time allocations for jobs. Nick also appeared to provide costly ancillary services that Mike believed were unnecessary. Mike tried to raise the issue with Nick, but the latter claimed that, as an experienced professional, he was well aware of what was best for his clients and that he had received no complaints.

Mike eventually discussed the issue personally with the senior partner Abel Bright who was responsible for the Albany operations. Abel appeared somewhat sympathetic, but countered that Nick was generating a lot of business and while he had not received any major complaints from his clients he was reticent to any problems at this time. He reassured Mike that he would nevertheless keep the matter under review.

The months went by and both accountants were subjected to a periodic appraisal by senior partners. Mike was counselled about the relatively high level of accounts receivable he was generating and was encouraged to concentrate more attention on gaining business from cashed up local businesses. Nick Iles continued with his policy of overcharging clients and keeping them ignorant of his service and pricing strategies.

Mike was becoming quite distressed. Nick's activities meant that he has generating up to forty percent more revenue each month than Mike. Mike made a final plea to Abel Bright about his colleague's apparent unethical practices and threatened to cease employment with the company unless something was done. Abel Bright made no response to the threat and offered no immediate solution to the problem.

Required

1. a) Briefly describe the Utilitarian approach to ethical reasoning and illustrate using information from the case study.

2. b) Select Abel Bright as the principal stakeholder and refer to at least another four (4) stakeholders affected by the dilemma. Why do you select each of them?

3. c) In normative terms, clearly define the main ethical dilemma facing Abel Bright when Mike Howard rang threatening his resignation over his colleague's unprofessional activities.

4. d) Identify at least three (3) alternative courses of action that Abel Bright could consider taking after speaking with Mike.

Note: Book : Psaros, J., Australian Corporate Governance: A review and analysis of key issues, 2009 or onwards. Pearson Education Australia.

(ISBN/ISSN: 9781442500259)

Subject: ACCT5029 CPA Ethics and Governance

Reference no: EM132642161

Questions Cloud

How the techniques should be classified and ranked : Submit a report that discusses the techniques used by malware developers to disguise their code and prevent it from being analyzed. Give suggestions on how.
Formulate and support organizational strategies : What does it mean to have bounded rationality in making ethical decisions that formulate and support organizational strategies? Support your answer.
Industrialization after the civil war : After the Civil War, the United States became a much more industrialized society. Between 1865 and 1920, industrialization improved American life in many ways.
Discuss ideas about the usefulness for the it manager : Review and summarize your ideas about the usefulness for the IT manager of a) a glossary that defines terms; b) the course readings; and c) working on a team.
Describe the utilitarian approach to ethical reasoning : Mike Howard and Nick Iles were ACCAs who were contracted by a Perth based second tier accounting practice, Bright, Candle and Light Partnership to supply a rang
How organizational culture impacts the success of innovation : Discuss what organizational culture is and how it impacts work productivity. Also, note how organizational culture impacts the success of innovation.
Analyze current health care delivery structure : Analyze the current health care delivery structure in your state. Compare and contrast the major determinants of healthcare market power.
Redraw complete causal loop diagram with explanation : Redraw complete causal loop diagram with explanation. Walk through the feedback loop and then determine if it is balancing or reinforcing
Demonstrate effective communication skills : Required to induct and brief one of the coaches and one of the trainees which has matched

Reviews

Write a Review

Finance Basics Questions & Answers

  Financial reporting and analysis

Finance is about Gunns Ltd, a company in dealing with forestry products in Australia. The company has also been listed in Australian Stock Exchange. As many companies producing forestry products, even Gunns Ltd is facing various problems. Due to the ..

  A report on financial accounting

This report is specific for a core understanding for Financial Accounting and its relevant factors.

  Describe the types of financial ratios

Describe the types of financial ratios and other financial performance measures that are used during venture's successful life cycle.

  Differences between sole proprietorship and corporation

Briefly describe the major differences between a sole proprietorship and a corporation

  Prepare a cash budget statement

Calculate the expected value of the apartment in 20 years' time. What is the mortgage loan repayment at the beginning of each month

  What are the implied interest rates

What are the implied interest rates in Europe and the U.S.?

  State pricing theory and no-arbitrage pricing theory

State pricing theory and no-arbitrage pricing theory

  Small business administration

Identify the likely stage for each venture and describe the type of financing each venture is likely to be seeking and identify potential sources for that financing.

  Effect of financial leverage

The Effect of Financial Leverage and working capital management

  Evaluate the basis for the payment to the lender

Evaluate the basis for the payment to the lender and basis for the payment to the company-counterparty.

  Importance of opps, ipps, mpfs and dmepos

Research and discuss the differences and importance of : OPPS, IPPS, MPFS and DMEPOS.

  Time value of money

Time Value of Money project

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd