Davids fifth amendment privilege against self incrimination

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131377488

A national bank was robbed by a man with a small strip of tape on each side of his face. An indictment was returned against David. David was then arrested, and counsel was appointed to represent him. Two weeks later, without notice to David's lawyer, an agent with the Federal Bureau of Investigation arranged to have the two bank employees observe a lineup, including David and five or six other prisoners.

Each person in the lineup wore strips of tape, as had the robber, and each was directed to repeat the words ‘‘Put the money in the bag,'' as had the robber. Both of the bank employees identified David as the robber.

At David's trial he was again identified by the two, in the courtroom, and the prior lineup identification was elicited on cross-examination by David's counsel.

David's counsel moved the court either to grant a judgment of acquittal or alternatively to strike the courtroom identifications on the ground that the lineup had violated David's Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination and his Sixth Amendment right to counsel. Decision?

Reference no: EM131377488

Questions Cloud

Examination of all forensic disciplines : This debate began back in 2009 and continues to this day. The initial concerns arose during a national examination of all forensic disciplines. This resulted in the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) report NRC 2009, "Strengthening Forensic Scienc..

Were donalds constitutional rights violated : Donald challenged the constitutionality of the search warrant. Were Donald's constitutional rights violated? Explain your answer.

Is market share the best indicator of company performance : "Market Share is the best indicator of company performance." Is this a reasonable statement?

What effect would this have on the total rate of corrosion : Aluminum plates are fastened together with brass rivets. The aluminum plates have a total exposed area of 1.5 ft.2 and the rivets have a total exposed area of 2.5 in.2. The environment involves moisture and some salt.

Davids fifth amendment privilege against self incrimination : David's counsel moved the court either to grant a judgment of acquittal or alternatively to strike the courtroom identifications on the ground that the lineup had violated David's Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination and his Sixth ..

How would you respond to the boards desire : How would you respond to the Board's desire for a return on investment from this initiative? Do you believe that the board's request is a reasonable one? Why or why not?

Describe how such an apparatus might be used : Figure P9.18 shows a rotating cylinder pressed against a second rotating cylinder. The cylinders rotate in opposite directions as shown. Describe how such an apparatus might be used.

How can you demonstrate something without any visuals : Visual aids are required-How can you demonstrate something without any visuals? Follow the Tips for Presenting Visual Aids from the textbook. Bring all necessary materials, ingredients, supplies, as well as a finished product

Explain whether waronek was guilty of crime of embezzlement : Shortly thereafter, he was arrested by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and indicted for the embezzlement of goods moving in interstate commerce. Explain whether Waronek was guilty of the crime of embezzlement.

User Account

All Pages