Critically discuss the major ethical issues

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13230186

The activities of the Australian Wheat Board (AWB) were in the news almost every day during the first part of 2006. The scandal relates to the period after 1996 when the United Nations set up the oil-for-food program. Since the program was introduced, the AWB continued to sell wheat to Iraq. In early 2006 AWB was accused of paying kickbacks totalling $280 million to Saddam Hussein's regime using a Jordanian trucking company, Alia to disguise the payments. This would be violation of oil-for-food program. Cole inquiry was set up to establish the truth of this claim. While the details are complicated and there is controversy about who knew what when, for the purposes of this assignment accept that it is true that the AWB did pay the kickbacks, that AWB senior management knew that this was what happened and in paying the kickbacks they violated the law. Also for the purpose of this assignment, focus only on the actions of AWB and ignore the role that government ministers may have played in the scandal.

You are at a dinner party and you overhear the following the comment about the scandal:

James: I don't understand what all the fuss is about. Everyone knows in the part of the world kickbacks are just part of everyday business. Think of it this way: The Iraqi people received the wheat they desperately needed, The AWB got a good price for the wheat even though they had to pay for the kickback and the farmers who produced the wheat received a good price for it. Where is the problem?

TASK:

1. Critically discuss the major ethical issues raised by the AWB scandal. You are required to make references to the unit materials and need to do scholar research to support your discussion.

2. How would you response James if you were a Utilitarian?

3. How would you response James if you were Kantian?

4. Sarah is there and joins the discussion saying "I cannot believe you said that!!!". She clearly disagrees with James. Construct the strongest possible argument to demonstrate this view is untenable.

Reference no: EM13230186

Questions Cloud

Why do human resource objectives essential for the company : Why do human resource objectives essential for the company to succeed?
Write a method, insertat, that takes four parameters : write a method, insertAt, that takes four parameters: an array of integers; the length of the array; an integer, say insertItem; and an interger, say, index.
Issue of strategic importance to that audience : Choose an emerging trend that has been published on a trend website, in the newspaper or some other publication and choose an audience and an issue of strategic importance to that audience
Write a program that uses a recursive method for palindome : palindome is a string that reads the same both forward and backward. For example,the string "madam" is a palindrome. write a program that uses a recursive method to check whether a string is a palindome.
Critically discuss the major ethical issues : Critically discuss the major ethical issues raised by the AWB scandal. You are required to make references to the unit materials and need to do scholar research to support your discussion.
Analyse the australian car manufacturing industry : Analyse the Australian car manufacturing industry by performing a 5 forces analysis and a life cycle analysis.
What cryptographic techniques would be used : Alice's Remanufactured Auto Parts is located in St. Louis, Missouri. Due to the popularity of the lowered price and high quality of remanufactured parts, Alice wants to expand operations to the World Wide Web.
Constructing and hedging investment portfolios : You are required to describe, with examples, the range of alternative investments which are generally available on capital and other markets and to consider how they are used in constructing and hedging investment portfolios.
Explain oogonia nolonger exist after birth : The smooth muscle walls of the ductus deferens are capableof peristalsis, Detection of uterine cancer is accomplished bya Pap smear, THe ovaries are held in place byfat capsules, Urine and sperm are able to passthrough the urethra at the same time, O..

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Evaluate ethics theory and issues

Demonstrate your capacity to understand and evaluate ethics theory and issues and understand the diversity of others and appreciate the value of ethical practice

  Yolande and shani control the business

Yolande and Shani control the business, and Wei, who is Yolande's boyfriend, has little interest in the company and little knowledge about its affairs.

  He says business is different from society standard

According to Albert Carr (1995, p12), "He says business is different from society standard" (Shaw 1995). The game of business is like a game of poker. There are a few number of things are allowable in the business context such as lying about one's..

  Explain advertising- puffery and the ftc

Explain Advertising- Puffery and the FTC and What is puffery and why does the FTC allow it occur in advertising

  Discriminated by the government

If a person has been discriminated by the government on the basis of the fact that he/she is an illegitimate child, the regulation will be evaluated under:A) due process B) intermediate scrutiny

  Conduct a warrantless search of a car interior

Under what circumstances may officers conduct a warrantless search of a car interior when the occupant has just been arrested? Please explain detail and give proper Bluebook citation references to your source. Remember this is an essay not a sh..

  Evaluate your legal rights as a franchisee

Evaluate your legal rights as a franchisee to determine if they favor the franchisor or the franchisee, or both equally and list the factors involved in determining a site for your franchise.

  Office plus, an office supply store

Office Plus, an office supply store, ordered 600 blank CDs from Curtis Co., a manufacturer of computer products. Office Plus placed the order using a preprinted purchase order form; Curtis acknowledged the order by sending a preprinted acceptance for..

  The bisulphite of soda

The bisulphite of soda couldn't be seen on a reasonable inspection by either the retailer or the buyer.

  Explain employment law- polygraph tests

Explain Employment Law- Polygraph Tests and What if the employee volunteers (suggests) the use of a polygraph test to prove his

  South spoon or south fork

Determine if the seller has a specific title such as Lord or Lady b) determine if the property has a title such as "South Spoon or South Fork"

  Explain employment and age discrimination

Explain Employment and Age Discrimination and Carter brings a claim of age discrimination against Warren

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd