Cost-benefit analysis included new methods

Assignment Help Operation Management

Reference no: EM131421548

To ensure highway safety and protect driver health, Congress charged federal agencies with regulating the hours of service of commercial motor vehicle operators. Between 1940 and 2003, the regulations that applied to long- haul truck drivers were mostly unchanged. (Long-haul drivers are those who operate beyond a 150-mile radius of their base.) In 2003, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMSCA) revised the regulations significantly, increasing the number of daily and weekly hours that drivers could work. The agency had not considered the impact of the changes on the health of the drivers, however, and the revisions were overturned. The FMSCA then issued a notice that it would reconsider the revisions and opened them up for public comment. The agency analyzed the costs to the industry and the crash risks due to driver fatigue under different options and concluded that the safety benefits of not increasing the hours did not outweigh the economic costs. In 2005, the agency issued a rule that was nearly identical to the 2003 version. Public Citizen, Inc., and others, including the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, asked the U. S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit to review the 2005 rule as it applied to long-haul drivers.

The agency’s cost-benefit analysis included new methods that were not disclosed to the public in time for comments. Was this unethical? Should the agency have disclosed the new methodology sooner? Why or why not?

The agency created a graph to show the risk of a crash as a function of the time a driver spent on the job. The graph plotted the first twelve hours of a day individually, but the rest of the time was depicted with an aggregate figure at the seventeenth hour. This made the risk at those hours appear to be lower. Is it unethical for an agency to manipulate data? Why or why not?

2-3 paragraphs

Reference no: EM131421548

Questions Cloud

Consider internal job structures with external market : Compensation surveys can be helpful when used appropriately. From what you learn about them, here's your chance to apply it to your job or future position. Then, consider internal job structures with external market pay rates for establishing base pa..

Probably the main characteristic of the trained thinker : Many years ago an expert on thinking made this observation: “probably the main characteristic of the trained thinker is that he does not jump to conclusions on insufficient evidence as the untrained man is inclined to do.” Think of several recent occ..

Different ways when discussing organizational life : Culture is an area that we focus on in different ways when discussing organizational life. Culture is difficult to define, but it holds the key to individual behavior and ethical environments within organizations. Describe the values, beliefs, and as..

What ethical standard sets the tone for the report : As you read, identify the types of ethical arguments being made, and determine whether there is an overall ethical standard to the Vision 2050 report. What ethical standard sets the tone for the report ? Do you support the conclusions about business ..

Cost-benefit analysis included new methods : To ensure highway safety and protect driver health, Congress charged federal agencies with regulating the hours of service of commercial motor vehicle operators. Between 1940 and 2003, the regulations that applied to long- haul truck drivers were mos..

Modern story about ethical values : A MODERN STORY ABOUT ETHICAL VALUES Privately rank the five characters in the following story from “best”=No 1, to “worst”= No. 5, according to your personal values. An older woman alone and homeless (whether from her husband’s death, divorce, or dru..

Distributions impact business inventory strategy : How do different probability distributions impact business inventory strategy? Would your decision change based on the change to the distribution model?

Humane treatment of the people who make our products : Many types of manufacturing operations have been moved overseas in a quest for lower labor costs. Many other nations have few, if any, laws that protect workers from abuse. To what extent do you agree with the vice president's statement: "We are mora..

Whose apprentice removed stone and refused to return : A chimney sweep found a jewel and took it to a goldsmith, whose apprentice removed the stone and refused to return it. The chimney sweep sues the goldsmith. A traveling salesperson leaving a store notices a parcel of bank notes on the floor. He picks..

User Account

All Pages