Conflict between federal and state statutes

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM133310610

Question: Clinton brings a diversity suit in federal court against Fisk for negligence. To prove Fisk's negligence, Clinton offers 2 days of testimony by an eminent (and expensive) expert on accident reconstruction. Clinton wins at trial and moves to collect as "costs" a $10,000 fee he paid to the expert to review the facts, perform experiments, and prepare for trial. The relevant federal statute, 28 USC §1920, provides that the prevailing party may recover certain limited types of costs of suit from the losing party. These costs include an attendance fee for witnesses who testify at trial but do not include a provision for recovering an expert's fee for preparing for trial. By contrast, a state statute provides that the prevailing party in a negligence case may recover the full costs of retaining expert witnesses.

1. Is there a conflict between the federal and state statutes?

2. How should the judge rule on the motion?

Analyze this problem under Hanna v. Plumer (1965). Please explain/elaborate on answers for 1 and 2. Also, for 2, is recovering costs a procedural or substantive issue and why?

 

Reference no: EM133310610

Questions Cloud

What do we mean by family in australia : What do we mean by family in Australia? Is religion relevant in Australia today? Give a personal opinion about the relevance of religion in Australia
How have you helped them overcome this : Give an example of a young person in your care who could be the subject of multiple discrimination, how have you helped them overcome this
How does residential childrens home setting ensure : How does residential childrens home setting ensure that the children's wishes and feelings are heard (include as many examples you can think of)
What should the patient do with the drugs : You know how to approach a patient with chronic pain. Does the information in this law add to your knowledge? In your opinion, should the government dictate
Conflict between federal and state statutes : Is there a conflict between the federal and state statutes? How should the judge rule on the motion?
Plan and implement in the school setting : Plan and implement in the school setting, or in a simulated setting, a learning activity for students aged 10 to 11 years, in a remote community
Critically reflect on the impact of intersectionality : Critically reflect on the impact of intersectionality on individuals' experience in the workplace. Please use examples, reflecting on at least two intersections
Describe deviance as being relative : What do sociologists mean when they describe deviance as being relative? Provide an example of a deviant behavior and identify how it is relative
People acquired peacocks and kept them in their front yard : Several years went by and the neighborhood grew. Brian and some other people acquired peacocks and kept them in their front yard.

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Describe the plan for communicating the change

Create a narrated PowerPoint presentation of 5 or 6 slides with video that presents a comprehensive plan to implement the change you propose.

  Which type of authorization is generated

Prior to discharge, the nursing case manager's most critical action is to: Which type of authorization is generated when services are rendered?

  Professional nursing organizations

Post a description of the health policy you selected and a brief background for the problem or issue being addressed. Explain whether you believe there is an ev

  Identify a treatment approach that you think best addresses

Select one treatment outcome model that you think would be the most effective for measuring the success of your selected treatment approach.

  Promotion of women is limited

Do you believe the promotion of women is limited due to the lack of a desire to pay the women more money or is it that women are paid a lower wage for the same reason(s) such a small number are promoted to CEO of very powerful companies?

  Create an argument supporting three items in the act

We know that the Sarbanes-Oxley Act was created as the result of several high-profile fraud cases. Now that the act is over 10 years old.

  Codes for california penal

Where can I find related legal codes for California? Provide a link to that site with a paragraph description of the types of laws contained there.

  Managing health information-right to privacy

Many health care organizations have implemented the electronic health record (EHR) system. Assess the issues that are being presented by the technology and evaluate the benefits against the issues.

  How the two theoretical lenses differ

Compare how the two theoretical lenses differ in terms of how the social worker would approach the client and the problem and how the social worker would.

  Describe their style of operation

Describe their style of operation? Why did they choose that particular target? What's the name of the group? Was their goal realistic?

  What do think about the chaos study definition

Do you think there are better definitions of success besides meeting scope, time, and cost goals? What do think about the CHAOS study definition

  Influence of bronfenbrenners ring

Determine the affect of Bronfenbrenner’s rings on each experience.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd