Compare and contrast the arguments of the speeches

Assignment Help History

Reference no: EM13228294

As you know by this point, the debates over the Compromise of 1850 proved vicious and intense. Read the 3 speeches about the Compromise of 1850 (provided in the Reading & Study folder of Module/Week 8), 1 penned by William Henry Seward (a powerful New York politician), 1 by John C. Calhoun, and 1 by Daniel Webster. Two are against the bill (Seward from an abolitionist perspective and Calhoun from that of slavery), and 1 is in favor of Clay's bill (Webster). Pay close attention to Seward's speech, as he references a higher law we must obey. He is referring to God's Law.

Question: Compare and contrast the arguments of the speeches. Which argument do you find the most compelling? Why?

Reference no: EM13228294

Questions Cloud

What conditions should underlie government according to penn : Why does Penn hesitate to prescribe a particular model of government as the best? What conditions should underlie any government according to Penn? What are the consequences of ignoring these ideals?

Major events that led to the outbreak of world war ii : xamine three of the major events that led to the outbreak of World War II. Explain the manner in which each of the events you have chosen contributed to starting the War. Provide a rationale for your response.

Contrast two major leaders in the civil war : Compare and contrast two major leaders in the Civil War, 1861-1 865. Discuss their contributions to the war, their successes and failures, and how they influenced the outcome of the war

Differ politically and economically from those in 1650 : How did the British North American colonies in 1750 differ politically and economically from those in 1650? Were there important continuities?

Compare and contrast the arguments of the speeches : Compare and contrast the arguments of the speeches. Which argument do you find the most compelling? Why?

According to the nineteenth-century science of phrenology : According to the nineteenth-century "science" of phrenology, what could be discerned from the shape of an individual's skull? The nineteenth-century practice of placing American Indians on reservations was partially designed to

Antislavery sentiments had existed prior-american Revolution : Although antislavery sentiments had existed prior to the American Revolution, the abolition movement did not gain sufficient momentum until about 1830.

Many historians consider the Battle of Gettysburg in 1863 : Many historians consider the Battle of Gettysburg in 1863 the turning point of the Civil War. Do you think that opinion is justified? What do you think was the most significant outcome of this battle? Why?

Erastus corning-battle of gettysburg-alexander gardner : One of a group of copperheads that passed a series of resolutions accusing the Lincoln administration of having acted unconstitutionally in placing military authority over civil authority.

User Account

All Pages