Companies afraid of terminating unproductive employees

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM132257099

The threat of litigation is making companies skittish about axing problem workers.

Would you have dared fire Hemant K. Mody? In February, the longtime engineer had returned to work at a GE facility in Plainville, Connecticut, after a two-month medical leave. He was a very unhappy man. For much of the prior year, he and his superiors had been sparring over his performance and promotion prospects. According to court documents, Mody’s bosses claimed he spoke disparagingly of his co-workers, refused an assignment as being beneath him, and was abruptly taking days off and coming to work late. But Mody was also 49, Indian born, and even after returning from leave, he continued to suffer a major disability: chronic kidney failure that required him to receive daily dialysis.

The run-ins resumed with his managers, whom he had accused flat out of discriminating against him because of his race and age. It doesn’t take an advanced degree in human resources to recognize that the situation was a ticking time bomb. But Mody’s bosses were fed up. They fired him in April. The bomb exploded in July 2006. Following a six-day trial, a federal court jury in Bridgeport, Connecticut, found GE’s termination of Modyto be improper and awarded him $11.1 million, including $10 million in punitive damages. But the award wasn’t for discrimination. The judge found those claims so weak that Mody wasn’t allowed to present them. Instead, jurors concluded that Mody had been fired in retaliation for complaining about bias. GE sued to have the award overturned but was only able to get the award reduced by $5 million in 2007. Unfortunately, Mody never saw any of the 2006 jury award; he died in April 2007 of a heart attack.

If this can happen to GE, a company famed for its rigorous performance reviews, with an HR operation that is studied worldwide, it can happen anywhere. The result: Many companies today are gripped by a fear of firing.

Terrified of lawsuits, they let unproductive employees linger, lay off coveted workers while retaining less valuable ones, and pay severance to nonperformers and even crooks in exchange for promises that they won’t sue. The fear of firing is particularly acute in the HR and legal departments. They don’t directly suffer when an underperformer lingers in the corporate hierarchy, but they may endure unpleasant indirect consequences if that person files a lawsuit.

When Mody signed GE’s job application in 1998, the form said his employment was “at will” and “the Company may terminate my employment at any time for any reason.” Well, not exactly. The notion that American workers are employed “at will”—meaning, as one lawyer put it, you can be fired if your manager doesn’t like the color of your socks—took root in the laissez-faire atmosphere of the late 19th century and, as an official matter, is still the law of the land in every state, save Montana. For most American workers now, their status as at-will employees has been transformed by a succession of laws growing out of the civil rights movement in the 1960s that bar employers from making decisions based on such things as race, religion, sex, age, and national origin. This is hardly controversial. Even the legal system’s harshest critics find little fault with rules aimed at ensuring that personnel decisions are based on merit. Most freely acknowledge that it is much easier to fire people in the United States than it is in, say, most of Western Europe. Mass layoffs, in fact, are a recurring event on the American corporate scene. Yet even in these situations, RIFs, or “reductions in force,” are carefully vetted by attorneys to assess the impact on employees who are in a legally protected category. These days the majority of American workers fall into one or more such groups. Mody, for example, belonged to three because of who he was (age, race, and national origin) and two more because of things he had done (complained of discrimination and taken medical leave). That doesn’t mean such people are immune from firing. But it does mean a company will have to show a legitimate, nondiscriminatory business reason for the termination, should the matter ever land in court.

1. Why are many companies afraid of terminating unproductive employees?

2. Why do supervisors bear much of the blame when HR says someone can’t be shown the door?

3. Can managers really fire employees “at will”?

4. GE was successful in getting the amount of the award reduced, but was the size of the award really its first concern?

5. Relate your personal experience, and apply what you learned. Indicate how you would have handled the situation if you were the primary subject in the case study, the subordinate in the case study, a supervisor or an outsider witnessing the situation.

Reference no: EM132257099

Questions Cloud

Describe a type of group you would like to facilitate : Group work offers many benefits that cannot be achieved through individual therapy alone. The most obvious benefit is group member validation.
About protected grounds and accommodation : We’ve been learning about protected grounds and accommodation.
Writing the definition of intelligence : The definition of intelligence is controversial. Briefly contrast different views of intelligence, making sure you take into account the content of at least.
Tesla to solve production line problems : What should do Tesla to solve production line problems? please provide many solutions with details ?
Companies afraid of terminating unproductive employees : Why are many companies afraid of terminating unproductive employees? Why do supervisors bear much of the blame when HR says someone can’t be shown the door?
Draw a UML diagram for class and then implement the class : For this assignment, you will create an Account class, UML diagram for the class and then implement the class by writing a test program
Examining the research in human development : Before completing this discussion, review Chapter 6 in your text. After examining the research in human development, please complete the following discussion.
Identify few ethical dilemmas in decision-making : Identify a few ethical dilemmas in decision-making that the conference leadership team faced and briefly explain, using chapter support,
Describe the effects of drugs on the body : For this discussion choose two of the drugs listed in this Module. For each one, indicate (1) their official name, (2) their "street names", (3) the "category".

Reviews

Write a Review

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Safety needs-social-esteem needs-self-actualization needs

Which of the following needs are fulfilled by Charity more than the other managers? Safety needs Social needs Esteem needs Self-actualization needs.

  What is the likelihood of success of threatened litigation

You are the HR manager for Appalachian Valley College, a fully-accredited private Baptist college located in western Virginia. While your college does not offer ministerial degrees, What is the likelihood of success of Dr. Madison’s threatened litiga..

  Nonmaterial elements of power include what

The Iran-Contra scandal resulted from the activities of which government agency?

  Ford motor company is more than 100 years old

Ford Motor Company is more than 100 years old? Why take the step to change supplier relationships now?

  Support service delivery by ensuring an inviting

The three subsystems that support service delivery by ensuring an inviting and supportive atmosphere, an effective organization,

  Sample of homeowners in the state of illinois

A sample of homeowners in the state of Illinois is desired for a major segmentation study conducted by a large financial institution.

  What is the difference between the four levels of management

What is the difference between the four levels of management. What is the difference between a discussion and a dialogue?

  Picks up on evidence of malicious activity

Most corporate security incidents are uncovered by a third party, like a security ?rm, that picks up on evidence of malicious activity. Why do you think IT security experts and not LinkedIn discovered the data breach?

  Discuss about the blocks of the business model canvas

Please include and executive summary at the beginning. Explain the success or failure of this venture using these 9 building blocks.

  Balance sheet-statement of cash flows and income statement

Calculate at least two key ratios for each financial statement from two institutions—balance sheet, statement of cash flows, and income statement.

  Discuss the rise of new global values

What is an ethic and compliance program? is it being followed by companies? Discuss the rise of new global values.

  Speech-making abilities in the future

You will create a speech that should be three to five minutes long. You must also have a transcript (print version) of your speech and include a short 75-word reflection statement. In the reflection statement, discuss what aspects of this assignment ..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd