Case-racist comments and sexual harassment

Assignment Help HR Management
Reference no: EM133030664

CASE 1 - Racist comments and sexual harassment leads to resignation

The complainant, who was of North African descent, alleged that he was subject to racist remarks from co-workers and later his supervisor. This included: calling him offensive names, such as frog , Borat , and boat person ; asking if he had spent time in a detention center; and mimicking the complainant's accent. Also, the complainant claimed that his direct supervisor commented negatively about his religious customs.

The complainant also alleged he had been subjected to sexual harassment, including making jokes about performing oral sex on his supervisor and customers to finalize sales. The complainant eventually resigned from his position after his complaints did not resolve the issues.

At conciliation, the supervisor refuted the allegations raised against him, and said that his working relationship with the complainant had initially been a positive one in which they enjoyed working together, but that the complainant had performance issues. The representative from the organization expressed his shock at the complaint and his disbelief that there was a poor workplace culture within his organization, and agreed to remedies to support staff.

The parties agreed on the following settlement during conciliation:

  • a written apology by the corporate respondent
  • a written statement of regret by the individual respondent
  • financial compensation
  • training for 250 staff on the Anti-Discrimination Act, and the internal and external complaint mechanisms available to all staff.

CASE 2 - Religion not a genuine requirement for position

A woman worked as a volunteer for the charity, St Vincent De Paul Society. The society's rules described it as an international Catholic organisation of lay people that seeks to help those who are suffering. The woman was not Catholic, but described herself as a Christian. She worked for the society for six years and during that time she had been elected president of a conference group. The society knew the woman was not Catholic when she was appointed president.

During a meeting the woman was told that not being Catholic had become a matter of contention for some members, and if she did not become Catholic, she could not continue to work for the society as president of a conference group and would have to either resign as president or resign from working for the society completely. The tribunal held that the ultimatum amounted to direct discrimination.

The tribunal considered whether the general exemption for religious bodies applied (s.109) and whether the genuine occupational exemption applied (s.25). The society was made up of 'lay faithful' and only one of its objectives was spiritual. The tribunal decided the society was not a religious body. It also concluded that inculcating the faith was not the society's primary function and it was not objectively necessary for a president to be Catholic. Spiritual roles were not a primary responsibility of a president, and the duties of a president were much more comprehensive.

The woman suffered severe depression as a result of the treatment of her by the society, and was awarded $25,000 in general damages, $500 for out-of-pocket expenses, and $2,000 for future psychiatric treatment. The tribunal declined to order the society to apologize because it acted on the basis of genuinely held beliefs.

Walsh v St Vincent de Paul Society Queensland (No. 2) [2008] QADT 32 (12 December 2008).

By considering these two cases, please answer following questions briefly 

  1. Individually identify the most important facts surrounding the case.
  2. Individually identify the key issue or issues.
  3. Specify alternative courses of action.
  4. Evaluate each course of action.
  5. Recommend the best course of action.

Reference no: EM133030664

Questions Cloud

How you can use the information shared in the readings : Discuss how you can use the information shared in the readings and the MSW Practice Education Manual to help you succeed at your practicum site
Skill development and application of social work : Create activities and tasks that will show your skill development and application of social work values, advanced generalist practice knowledge
Draw the free body diagrams : Determine the magnitude and orientation of the reaction force at supports A and C and Draw the free body diagrams
Discuss the potential challenges of market entry strategy : Q.1 A successful "heavy machinery manufacturer" from Canada want to expand their business internationally. One such country where they want to expand is in Indo
Case-racist comments and sexual harassment : The complainant, who was of North African descent, alleged that he was subject to racist remarks from co-workers and later his supervisor. This included: callin
Minimize the total cost of waiting line system : An average of 40 customers per hour arrives at a bank branch office (Poisson arrival) and wait in a single line to be served by the first available teller.
Learning technique for classification problems : We learned about why logistic regression is the most basic form of parametric supervised learning technique for classification problems.
Intentional infliction of emotional distress : In the case of tarasoff v paddor, Cal. case and in Boyton v burglass Florida case, was the tort for intentional infliction of emotional distress addressed? (IID
What is message c : Question #1: Encrypts the plaintext message A: "THIS IS ASSIGNMENT THREE" using Caesar ROT3 substitution cipher to get a ciphertext message B.

Reviews

Write a Review

HR Management Questions & Answers

  Improve problem solving capabilities within organization

Types of teams as to their effectiveness that will improve problem solving capabilities within organizations.

  Influence tactics help in reducing organizations politics

Explain the different types of influence tactics that will be of a help “if adopted” in reducing the organizational politics.

  Report on citigroup''s hr service level agreement

Human Resources or Human Resource Management deals with HR Service Level Agreement. HR Service Level Agreement is an agreement made between the employer and the employee, which states that the employee would work under any client and sometimes any ti..

  A project report on hrm

Human Resource Management as the name suggests, it is a management discipline which deals with the human i.e. the workforce aspect of organizations. Need and practices of HRM are inevitable in present scenario of extreme competition where "Talent War..

  Hrp: recruitment and selection

Recruitment and Selection is the initial ladder of any Human Resource Planning process and contains an immense significance for any organisation.

  A project report on study of statutory complainces

Statutory compliance and its immense knowledge are crucial to be understood in an organization. It contains all the forms, procedures and acts applicable in a company.

  Operant conditioning and Reinforcement

Operant conditioning is a learning process where behaviour is controlled by its consequences. In this process an individual's behaviour can be modified through the use of positive or negative reinforcement.

  Effectiveness of training programs in achieving customers an

The main motive for conducting this research is to provide broad range of research of the literature and their reviews related to training and development and assisting the employees in providing customers satisfaction.

  A critical analysis of hr processes and practices in fedex c

FedEx is illustrious for its novel HR processes and practices that have greatly accounted for its success.

  Integrating culture and diversity in decision making

People in the organization are known as Google where they share common goals and have common vision.

  Impact of employee attrition on people management in organis

Talent management implies recognizing a person's inherent skills, traits, personality and offering him a matching job.

  Labour dissonance at maruti suzuki india limited: a case stu

This Case Study focuses on various issues related to Labour Unrest at Maruti Suzuki India Limited.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd