Case of the sole remaining supplier

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13327593

The Case of the Sole Remaining Supplier

The heart pacemaker is a modern wonder. The device has a timer that resets itself every time the patient's heart beats. If the heart does not beat on schedule (say, within 1.2 seconds), the pacemaker gives a stimulus that causes a heartbeat.

But the technology was not always so sophisticated, and its early limitations form the background of this true story, told to Markkula Center for Applied Ethics Director Thomas Shanks, S.J., by one of the participants. Although the events happened 20 years ago, the ethical issues they raise are still relevant.

It's 1975, and you are on the board of directors of a company that makes transistors. Among the many companies with whom you have a contract is one that makes heart pacemakers.

Pacemaker technology is in its infancy. When doctors implant a pacemaker, the patient's normal heartbeat is disabled, and he or she relies entirely on the device. If it fails, the patient's heart stops. Doctors are not very adept at installing the pacemakers, which are extremely delicate; there is even a story of a person yawning deeply, pulling the pacemaker wire in his chest, and dying.

After that and many similar incidents, the board begins to reconsider whether your company should sell to the pacemaker company. Members of the board feel this situation is a major lawsuit just waiting to happen and your company, as well as the company you supply, will be liable. In addition, you feel the specs the pacemaker company uses to test the transistors are not very strong.

You and the board decide to get out of the business before it's too late. You tell the pacemaker company representatives about your conclusion, and they respond, "You can't stop selling us the transistors. You are the sole remaining supplier for us. Everyone else has backed out for the same reasons you're giving. If you don't sell us the product, we'll go out of business. Pretty soon, no one will be making heart pacemakers, and many people need them. Without the pacemaker, people don't even have a chance."

You take that information back to the board. People around the table have different opinions. One person says, "This is a bad deal, and it isn't our problem. We don't make enough on this sale to make the risk worthwhile." Another person says, "We don't know how other companies use the transistors we sell them; why should we be concerned about this one? What about that baby who died when the transistor in the incubator failed? We didn't know how that company was using the transistor." Another person says, "I think we're missing the real issue here. Don't we have an ethical obligation to sell the product to the pacemaker company? What will happen if we don't sell to them?" Another person says, "Give me a break. Our only obligation is to our shareholders. And how did we get so stupid that we're the last source? I'm telling you, we don't need this." Finally, the chair of the board says, "OK. Let's make a decision."

What do you do?

What are the relevant facts to this case?

What are the ethical issues?

Who are the primary stakeholders?

What are the possible options?

What are the ethics of the options?

What decision would you make?

Reference no: EM13327593

Questions Cloud

Discuss the ramifications on the organization : How can leadership promote cultural diversity to create effective change? Discuss the ramifications on the organization for failing to accommodate cultural differences.
Influence of senior executives on organizational change : Recognize the influence of senior executives on organizational change and discuss possible strategies for building trust within the change process. Explain what pitfalls management must take care to avoid and include why.
Require frequent use of the horseshoe : Symbolize the following, which require frequent use of the horseshoe. Use only the abbreviations provided. J=John will make supper; W=Mary is working late; M=Mary will make supper; John=is working late; H=John is very hungry; B=John's boss requires h..
What is dengs wacc : Deng Inc. has a target debt-equity ratio of 0.4. It's before-tax  cost of equity is 16 %  and it's before-tax cost of debt is 8%. If the tax rate is 32%, what is Deng's WACC?
Case of the sole remaining supplier : The heart pacemaker is a modern wonder. The device has a timer that resets itself every time the patient's heart beats. If the heart does not beat on schedule (say, within 1.2 seconds), the pacemaker gives a stimulus that causes a heartbeat.
Major operator is not truth functional compound : Determine which of the following sentences are truth-functionally compound. Remember that if the major operator is not truth functional, then the sentence is truth functionally simple, rather than compound, and must be symbolized using single capital..
Ethical and legal environment of business : case: Burlington Northern & Sante Fe Railway Company v. Sheila White I am looking for Facts, Legal analysis, Ethical analysis and conclusions.
Legal sources according to hierarchy of the law discussed : You have been asked to review several different primary authorities for an assignment. Hopwever , in order to properly complete the assignment, you must be able to rank these resources by their precedential value.
Summarizing the texas state court system : Prepare a report in outline form summarizing the Texas State Court System. Highlight local and appellate courts for your home county. You should begin with an introductory paragraph describing the Texas Court System in general.

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Effective interpersonal communications

What role might effective interpersonal communications play in career advancement for a manager? Does good interpersonal skill help in career advancement.

  Zooxanthallae growing in its tissues

Which of these organisms would have zooxanthallae growing in its tissues?

  Training and development

You are a senior colorist at the cosmetic manufacturing company, Paint Me Pretty. You are also a Career Mentor for several other, more junior colorists. One of your mentees, Kitty Jones, is a colorist who is leading a project team for the third time ..

  Regularly collected rent for paulette

Paulette is the owner of the Rock On Mobile Home Park. For several years, Albert regularly collected rent for Paulette from the tenants of the mobile home park. Recently, Paulette learned that Albert pocketed some rent he collected, so Paulette fired..

  Maximum thickness of the gold layer covering the front face

What should be the maximum thickness of the gold layer covering the front face of a surface barrier detector used for the measurement of 10Mev alphas, if the energy loss of the alphas traversing the layer should be less than 0.1% of the kinetic energ..

  Explain what judicial review

Explain what judicial review is and how it affects the federal government. How did the Supreme Court attain this power? is it fair? Why or why not?

  Major issues and major development of american policing

Prepare a written response comparing and contrasting the major issues and major development of American Policing for the following time periods (1900 to 1959); (1960 to 1979); (1980 to 1999);

  Experiment to test whether alcohol consumption

Design an experiment to test whether alcohol consumption influence people's tendency to become socially agressive.

  Economic self-interest

What are the implications of explaining prejudice and discrimination as arising from ignorance rather than economic self-interest?

  Name a firm that is currently having financial difficulties

Please name a firm that is currently having financial difficulties. what might you suggest to this firm regarding the steps it can take to turn aroud its current situation

  Why are ammonites useful fossils for biostratigraphy

All of the following are direct or indirect effects of the production of flood basalts. Which would probably have the LEAST effect on the generation of a mass extinction event? Why are ammonites useful fossils for biostratigraphy?

  Sources of competitive advantage

What are the three sources of competitive advantage available to international businesses that are not available to purely domestic businesses?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd