Can the defendant use any affirmative defenses

Reference no: EM132661564

Assignment: Part 1: Research the case of Tennessee v. Garner, 471 U.S. 1 (1985). Provide the factual background of the case, the procedural history, and the issues and analysis confronted by the court in dealing with the issue of when a law enforcement officer may use deadly force. Are the guidelines set by the court clear, or do they provide a less than bright-line standard that a law enforcement officer must decide upon in a split second?

Part 2: Homework Assignments

1. Insanity Defense

A local business owner has been arrested for the nonfatal shooting of a competitor, who he said taunted him and destroyed his business reputation. The defendant is from a culture in which people who commit social wrongs make public apologies; in some cases, they commit suicide to show remorse. The defendant stated that his competitor slandered him to vendors and to customers. In addition, he refused to apologize when confronted and only laughed at the defendant. The defendant said that he was "out of his mind" with rage when he pulled the trigger. Answer the following questions:

a. Can the defendant use any affirmative defenses? Why, or why not?

b. Should the defendant be charged with any crime? Why, or why not? What crime?

2. Self-Defense

You are a police detective investigating a homicide case in which the defendant shot and killed a man who had broken into her apartment and threatened to rape her. He was eight inches taller and 60 pounds heavier than she is, and she stated that she feared for her life. Answer the following questions:

a. In such a case, is lethal force justified for self-defense? Why, or why not?

b. What other factors would you consider in a case such as this?

Reference no: EM132661564

Questions Cloud

Difference between reasonable suspicion and probable cause : Explain the difference between reasonable suspicion and probable cause. What is the exclusionary rule? What are situations in which officers can make a felony.

How through the means of art that the artist attempts : Select two classic painting and suggest how through the means of art that the artist attempts to convey meaning. Your primary posting should be 250 words.

Why does america have a dual-court system : What is the dual-court system(civil/criminal), and why does America have a dual-court system? Court unification involves consolidating many lower courts.

What role do hierarchy and authority have in given approach : The structural approach is one of the dominant approaches for the study of large-scale administration. What role do hierarchy and authority have.

Can the defendant use any affirmative defenses : A local business owner has been arrested for the nonfatal shooting of a competitor, who he said taunted him and destroyed his business reputation.

Describe the impact of personality disorders : Describe the impact of personality disorders on delinquency. Describe one social structure theory, one learning theory, and one social control theories.

Discuss the difference between crime spree and crime series : "Crime spree" and "crime series"; discuss the difference between them. Research current news and provide an example of both.The response must be typed.

What role the crime analyst had in crime fighting : Search on Internet using Google News with key term "Crime analyst catches criminal." What results did you receive? Select one news story and explain what role.

User Account

All Pages