Can the corporation be prosecuted

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131378431

Fred Pomeroy was an assistant traffic manager for the New York Central and Hudson River Railroad Company.

In that capacity, he handed out "rebates" to the American Sugar Refining Company in New York and New Jersey and to W. H. Edgar & Son in Detroit. The goal of the rebates was to convince the sugar refiner and the sugar dealer, to use the railroad for their shipments rather than some other method.

The problem with this arrangement was that the shipping rates were fixed by federal law and, thus, the rebates amounted to a bribe. Pomeroy and New York Central were prosecuted under the Elkins Act and were found guilty.

On an appeal that went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, New York Central argued that, while Pomeroy could be prosecuted under the criminal statute, the corporation could not. Can the corporation be prosecuted? What theory would you advise the court to use in this case? Explain. What will the outcome be?

(See New York Central & Hudson River Railroad v. United States, 212 U.S. 481 (U.S. Supreme Court).)

Reference no: EM131378431

Questions Cloud

What are the three standards for the insanity defense : What are the three standards for the insanity defense found in criminal law?- What are the requirements of entrapment as a defense against criminal liability?

Discuss the ability and disability in the parker case : Think of the many names and labels you may have heard to describe persons with disabilities and those that are currently socially acceptable. The changing monikers given to those with disabilities are evidence of the continual negotiation of the s..

Which of the following counseling theories would you prefer : Roberta has come to counseling because she is contemplating a divorce from her husband of 12 years. She has been unhappy in her marriage for several years and doesn't think that she and her husband can rekindle the interest necessary in their rela..

What are the last two tasks on the project critical path : What and when is the second milestone - What are the last two tasks on the project critical path? Furniture Delivery and Unpack

Can the corporation be prosecuted : Can the corporation be prosecuted? What theory would you advise the court to use in this case? Explain. What will the outcome be?

What was the result on appeal : In this case, it was clear that the agent had committed a crime but the acts were not within the scope of employment because he had been expressly forbidden to continue the boycott. What was the result on appeal? Explain.

Watch the video and give your reviews : Using only one case study and one counseling theory throughout your paper, provide a detailed response to each of the following questions. For example, if you chose Carol and Psychoanalytic Theory, you would answer all of the following questions ..

Purpose of the research proposal : The purpose of the research proposal is to help you to understand your project, to gain direction and feedback on your project, and to establish a blueprint for your project.

Develop an abbreviated concept paper : For this task, develop an Abbreviated Concept Paper, including an Introduction, Problem, Purpose, Questions, Literature Review (including a conceptual or theoretical framework), and an outline of the proposed Research Methods section.Your assignm..

User Account

All Pages