Can superior meet these requirements

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133193511 , Length: 2 pages

Case: Superior Wholesale Corporation planned to purchase Regal Furniture, Inc., and wished to deter-mine Regal's net worth. Superior hired Lynette Shuebke, of the accounting firm Shuebke Delgado, to review an audit that had been prepared by Norman Chase, the accountant for Regal. Shuebke advised Superior that Chase had performed a high-quality audit and that Regal's inventory on the audit dates was stated accurately on the general ledger. As a result of these representations, Superior went forward with its purchase of Regal.

After the purchase, Superior discovered that the audit by Chase had been materially inaccurate and misleading, primarily because the inventory had been grossly overstated on the balance sheet. Later, a former Regal employee who had begun working for Superior exposed an e-mail exchange between Chase and former Regal chief executive officer Buddy Gantry. The exchange revealed that Chase had cooperated in overstating the inventory and understating Regal's tax liability. Using the information presented in the chapter, answer the following questions.

Question 1 : If Shuebke's review was conducted in good faith and conformed to generally accepted accounting principles, could Superior hold Shuebke Delgado liable for negligently failing to detect material omissions in Chase's audit? Why or why not?

Question 2: According to the rule adopted by the majority of courts to determine accountants' liability to third parties, could Chase be liable to Superior? Explain.

Question 3: Generally, what requirements must be met before Superior can recover damages under Sec-tion 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and SEC Rule 10b-5? Can Superior meet these requirements?

Question 4: Suppose that a court determined that Chase had aided Regal in willfully understating its tax liability. What is the maximum penalty that could be imposed on Chase?

Reference no: EM133193511

Questions Cloud

Identify the assessments you recommend to validate treatment : Identify the assessments you recommend to validate treatment. Explain your recommendations for initial resources and treatment.

Select one you feel satisfies his concerns : Saudi electronic university - select one you feel satisfies his concerns. Make sure to explain why it is the best for Ahmad and Pennypacker.

Compile the daily average pressure of a city : Choose 4 different GLOBAL cities at the same time 2 from the northern and 2 from the southern hemisphere, and compile their daily average pressure

Explain role of the community health nurse in partnership : Explain the role of the community health nurse in partnership with community stakeholders for population health promotion

Can superior meet these requirements : Florida International University - Determine accountants' liability to third parties, could Chase be liable to Superior? Explain

How can social workers advocate for social change : How can Social Workers advocate for social change to reduce environmental challenges for the homeless IN SINGAPORE?

Analyzing the moral dilemmas : There are many different moral theories, each of which provides a different way of analyzing the moral dilemmas we face in our lives.

Discuss people responsibility as relates to health outcome : Question - Discuss people responsibility as it relates to health outcome. Address how socioeconomic factors might impact an individual's ability to be held

Does it matter to the out-come of this dispute explain : The brokerage firm challenges the rule in an action that ultimately is reviewed by a federal appellate court - SEC's interpretation of the law on insider

User Account

All Pages