Can state of inebriation law applied even after csa is pass

Reference no: EM133667235

Discussion Post: Constitutional Law

In response to various state laws legalizing the use of medicinal marijuana, the federal government amended the Controlled Substances Act ("CSA"). The CSA prohibits the manufacture, possession or distribution of marijuana. The legislative history indicates the CSA was designed, among other things, to deter state and local governments from "encouraging the intrastate distribution and possession of medicinal marijuana because such activity contributes to swelling interstate traffic in this substance." Penalties for violating the CSA include, but are not limited to, monetary fines.

Previously, the State of Inebriation had enacted the Compassionate Use of Marijuana Act ("CUMA"), which permits qualifying residents to "obtain and use marijuana for medical purposes where that medical use is deemed appropriate and has been recommended by a licensed physician."

CUMA conditions eligibility for the permit on the individual's residency in Inebriation for at least six months. The purposes of the residency requirement are two-fold: (I) "limit the burden on Inebriation's health care system from increased requests for medicinal marijuana use permits," and (II) "ensure that the permits will be issued in such a way as to promote residents' continued positive contributions to society." CUMA's principal sponsor, F. Theodore Higgins, commented on the Assembly floor. "we need CUMA's residency requirement to discourage migration of scam artists and miscreants." CUMA violators are subject to potential criminal and civil sanctions.

Joanne, who suffers from a debilitating medical condition, moved to Inebriation two months ago.

Joanne's new husband, Clarence, also has a debilitating medical condition, but he has resided in Inebriation for two years. Joanne and Clarence visit their Inebriation-based physician, Doctor, to obtain a medicinal marijuana permit. Despite Joanne's qualifying medical condition, Doctor advises he cannot issue her a medicinal marijuana permit. Doctor, however, does issue a permit to Clarence.

Clarence cultivates a small marijuana garden in the couple's backyard, and they both use the crop solely for their own medicinal purposes. The federal government discovers Clarence's garden, impounds the crop and issues him a civil citation. After a trial in federal court, Clarence is assessed a fine. Seeking to make an example of Joanne for her non-compliance, Inebriation issues her a civil citation. After an Inebriation court proceeding, Joanne is also fined.

After exhausting their respective appeals in the federal Circuit Court and Inebriation's Supreme Court, Joanne and Clarence's petitions for certification to the United States Supreme Court have been granted and consolidated.

You are a law clerk for the Supreme Court Justice assigned to prepare the bench memorandum discussing Joanne and Clarence's defenses raised in the proceedings below. Address the following three issues:

I. Is the CSA constitutional under the "commerce" clause? I.e., did Congress have the power to pass this law?

II. Can the State of Inebriation law be applied even after the CSA is passed? Why or why not?

III. Is the enforcement of either law a violation of the Constitutional guarantee of "equal protection"? Discuss.

Reference no: EM133667235

Questions Cloud

How is schizophrenia in relation to socialization : How does the sociological concept of culture relate to schizophrenia? How is schizophrenia in relation to socialization?

Early childhood education and care services : This includes systemic oppression of any kind, Which sector(s) of ECECS would best support this improvement?

Connection between personal troubles and social structures : "The quality of mind that enables one to see the connection between personal troubles and social structures and forces" (C. Wright Mills, 1959).

Different ethical and legal concerns : There are different ethical and legal concerns. How do you navigate issues related to patient autonomy, confidentiality, and consent?

Can state of inebriation law applied even after csa is pass : Is the CSA constitutional under the commerce clause? Can the State of Inebriation law be applied even after the CSA is passed? Why or why not?

The nurse is caring for client with acute pancreatitis : The nurse is caring for a client with acute pancreatitis. Which prescription will the nurse question before implementing?

The coding guidelines : For a patient, the doctor has documented alcohol use, abuse, and dependence. According to the coding guidelines, which code or codes should be assigned?

Identify the core principles of social justice : Identify the core principles of social justice. Describe how implicit bias impacts your understanding of the core principles of social justice.

When can employers require employees to speak english : Strict "English-only" rules are generally not defensible under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. When can employers require employees to speak English?

User Account

All Pages